Zuma vs Ramaphosa on transformation

Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa. File picture

Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa. File picture

Published May 2, 2017

Share

Johannesburg - “Radical economic transformation” has

become the South African government’s new mantra as it advocates giving the

nation’s black majority a bigger stake in the economy 23 years after the end of

white-minority rule.

What exactly it means is unclear. The phrase doesn’t

appear in the National Development Plan, the government’s economic blueprint,

and President Jacob Zuma and his deputy Cyril Ramaphosa have painted different

pictures of how it should be translated into policy.

Zuma is due to step down

as leader of the ruling African National Congress in December and as president

in 2019, and Ramaphosa is one of the front-runners to succeed him. Here’s what

they’ve been saying.

President Jacob

Zuma:

The constitution should be changed to allow the state to

seize land without having to pay for it to address skewed ownership patterns.

There must be a fundamental change in the structure, systems, institutions and

patterns of ownership, management and control of the economy to ensure it

benefits all South Africans, especially the poor, most of whom are African and

female.

Black-controlled companies must benefit more from the government’s R500

billion ($37 billion) annual procurement budget. More companies listed on

the Johannesburg Stock exchange should be owned by black people.

There should

be more black industrialists and farmers. Companies and the government should

do more to hire and promote black staff. Black and white professionals doing

the same job should be paid equally.

Deputy President

Cyril Ramaphosa

Radical economic transformation is a “national

imperative” and means building a more equal society and drawing more people

into the mainstream economy. While the constitution says the government should

pay just and equitable compensation for land, a code should be drafted spelling

out what this means and there should be a move away from paying market-related

rates.

Ownership patterns in the economy must change at a faster rate and in a

more meaningful manner to enable the country’s people to share in its wealth.

There needs to be a massive skills development drive to prepare young South

Africans for the workplace.

Agricultural land must be redistributed on a far

bigger scale and more speedily than is currently happening and the new owners

must be equipped to farm it productively. The government should use its

infrastructure investment program to build local manufacturing capacity and

where appropriate ensure contracts go to black-owned companies.

More black people

should become producers, financiers and business owners.

BLOOMBERG

Related Topics: