Murder not an entry into manhood

Comment on this story
IOL  ca p17 Four Corners DONE CAPE ARGUS Ian Gabriels recent film Four Corners raises serious questions youth face of joblessness and violence. Picture: David Ritchie

Gang rituals is no test of masculinity. There are macho alternative cultures full of justice and integrity, write Lesle Jansen and Kabir Bavikatte.

Cape Town - In a disturbing scene in Ian Gabriel’s recent film Four Corners, there is a monologue by Gasant, the leader of the 26 gang, to a group of young recruits about to embark on their first kill. Like a ritual elder at an initiation ceremony, Gasant tells the boys: “Now we got men’s work to do,” marking the murder they are about to commit as their entry into manhood.

The film raises powerful questions on youthful aggression, rites of passage and what it means to be a man. Whether the fires of our youth tend the hearth of the community or burn down its foundations depends on how we answer these questions.

The film got me thinking on rites of passage for boys in other cultures.

On a recent work trip to Japan, I went to the local budokan (martial arts training hall) to train with the judo club. At the budokan, the teacher, a man in his 70s, informed me that the word budo in budokan was the samurai version of the knightly code of chivalry.

It included qualities such as justice, benevolence, integrity, honour and discipline. He said judo meant the “gentle-way”. This didn’t mean that it wasn’t devastatingly effective, but rather that it was an art of sublimating raw aggression in a way that elegance overcame bluster.

I was amazed at how activities at the budokan seemed like a culturally rooted rite of passage for young men. Teachers taught various techniques all requiring courage, persistence and trust and performed with deadly earnest. The members were constantly reminded that they were entrusted with each other’s safety and their focus should be on aggressive play rather than winning at all costs.

At the budokan, to be a man was to epitomise budo. On the mat the young men threw, grappled, locked and choked with unmatched fury but lacked the meanness and cruelty symptomatic of frustrated aggression.

Even in the heat of combat, they displayed a sense of fair play and concern for each other’s safety. The few women members I spoke with said that not once did they feel uncomfortable or violated when training with the men. Instead, they felt supported and their boundaries were respected without any granting concessions.

My experience at the budokan reminded me of a time several years ago when I acted as a lawyer for the Samburu. The Samburu are pastoralists who roam the dusty and drought-prone plains of the lion-infested Rift Valley province in Kenya.

What intrigued me was despite their indifference to lions, as dusk approached the Samburu would hurry back to their kraals. I was also curious about the practice many of the Samburu men had of carrying AK-47s slung across their backs, an incongruity among pastoralists. On asking, I was told that they were concerned about cattle raiders who had killed a number of young men recently.

Apparently, the Samburu tribes have always had a rite of passage, in which an adolescent to be recognised as a man in his tribe had to steal cattle from another tribe. Cattle raids were conducted according to cultural norms that prohibited killing and gratuitous violence.

No tribe lost out on their cattle since they always stole back cattle from another tribe. Moreover, cattle raids ensured peace by creating camaraderie and competition among the young men of different tribes. This rite was designed to help boys channel their aggression as they entered manhood. I had witnessed similar rites to manhood among various indigenous peoples I had worked with.

However, the civil war in neighbouring Somalia had introduced AK-47s into this mix. Cattle raiders, owing no allegiance to any tribe, used it as a weapon of choice.

They roamed the Rift Valley, killing wantonly on their raids, and raided cattle not as a cultural practice, but for sale. In self-defence the Samburu men had taken to arming themselves, leading to dangerous times when minor conflicts could spiral out of control.

I came away from Kenya feeling that the Samburu were on to something. They had developed a rite of passage that embraced and directed youthful aggression to the service of the community. Though a long way off from rural Kenya, I had witnessed a similar sublimation of aggression at the budokan.

Youthful aggression was expressed in its most elemental form, at the level of the body, and then moulded into the high art of budo. The initiation to manhood in both these cultures involved ritualised aggression at the level of the body. The rituals initiated boys into a manhood that embodied authentic self-expression while caring for others.

These cross-cultural rites of passage bring us back to the questions posed by Four Corners. They ask for an honest discussion in South Africa on mature masculinity and how we raise boys. They force a conversation on wholesome rites of passage for boys, which replace gangs and positively channel youthful aggression in a dangerous age of gender, gang and xenophobic violence.

The natural fierceness of many men today seems to be infected with a desperation symptomatic of both rampant unemployment and soul-destroying urban service jobs.

We are witnessing a rise in overgrown boys who listlessly roam the streets, internet and malls unsure of what they are seeking but yearning to feel alive. At times their bottled up aggression makes them bullies who do appalling things to their families, neighbours and communities.

We will probably never be rid of this aggression. Instead, in the tradition of that old master of sublime aggression, Madiba, we must cultivate rites of passage that transform this unrefined energy into something majestic. We need to transcend insecure machismo and wear our masculinity with the dignity of a warm cloak that nurtures.

* Lesle Jansen and Dr Kabir Bavikatte co-ordinate the Heroes Project with Natural Justice (Lawyers for Communities and the Environment). The project complements legal strategies with psycho-social interventions that include rite-of-passage programmes. Jansen can be contacted at [email protected]

** The views expressed here are not necessarily those of Independent Newspapers.

Cape Argus



sign up
 
 

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.