Article Search

 Cop allegedly shoots three-year-old
    November 10 2009 at 07:03AM Get IOL on your
mobile at m.iol.co.za

Submit your comment

  • Gallery: Three-year-old shot dead in Midrand

    By Poloko Tau

    A single gunshot through the window of a parked car, and a three-year-old boy was dead. The shooter: a police constable.

    Atlegang Phalane, 3, was hit by a bullet while seated in the backseat of a white Hyundai with his uncle, Bongani Mchunu, around 6pm on Saturday.

    'They did not show any remorse afterwards'
    The car was parked outside a relative's house in Klipfontein View Extension 2, north-east of Joburg.

    Atlegang died instantly.

    Now his family are asking whether he was killed because of a shoot-to-kill instruction.
    Continues Below ↓





    "We were waiting for the driver when suddenly I heard the sound of tyres screeching as an unmarked VW Golf stopped next to us.

    "Then a gunshot followed. The bullet shattered the window on my side and hit Atlegang in the chest," Mchunu said.

    'My child was too young to die by the gun'
    "One officer in private clothing jumped out of the car and ordered me to the ground while the other removed Atlegang's body and placed it on the ground next to the car. They screamed at me, saying I was a suspect, but they would not say what I did."

    Mchunu said the officers did not ask a single question or fire a warning shot.

    "They fired even before they got out of the car. And then they did not even seem to care that Atlegang was wounded as they cuffed me.

    "Even if I was a criminal, were they supposed to just shoot at the car when I posed no danger to them? They did not show any remorse afterwards."

    The child's father, Vusi Mchunu, who arrived on the scene shortly afterwards, was arrested as he tried to get to his son, who was lying on the pavement. A third man, the owner of the car, was also arrested when he arrived.

    All three were taken to the Rabie Ridge police station.

    "They kept us there, and I was released later. But they still could not say what Atlegang's father and the owner of the car had done," Mchunu said.

    He said Vusi Mchunu was still being held at the Alexandra police station and was yet to be charged with a crime.

    It was not clear what had happened to the owner of the car.

    Seated on a mattress at her home in Klipfontein View, near Midrand, yesterday, Atlegang's mother, Mapule Phalane, said she was also not allowed to get close to her son's body on Saturday, even though it took almost six hours before a mortuary van arrived.

    "I stood there watching the man who had just shot my son sucking a lollipop as if nothing had happened.

    "My child was too young to die by the gun. Why did they just shoot? They then arrested his father, when all he wanted was to see his son's body. Is this what was meant by the shoot-to-kill statements?" she asked.

    Police have refused to comment on the incident.

    The Independent Complaints Directorate (ICD) said a Constable SS Malaka of the Alexandra detective branch was arrested on Saturday. He appeared in the Tembisa Magistrate's Court yesterday and was denied bail.

    ICD spokesman Moses Dlamini said police were tracing a suspect on Saturday and had information that he was at a particular address.

    "They arrived at the address and found a car outside the house. It is alleged one member saw a pipe which looked like a firearm, and he then fired in the direction of the pipe," Dlamini said.

    "A three-year-old boy was shot in the chest and died instantly. No pipe or firearm was recovered from the car."

    Atlegang's shooting comes less than a week after National Police Commissioner Bheki Cele was quoted as saying at a police graduation ceremony that officers have a right to return fire when shot at, but must not be trigger happy. "Don't be trigger happy, assess the situation properly. We must avoid the Mabopane incident," he said.

    Cele was referring to an incident in Mabopane, North West, last month when 28-year-old Olga Kekana was killed when police shot at the car she was travelling in as they believed it had been stolen.

    In another incident, Atteridgeville police allegedly shot dead 21-year-old Kgothatso Ndobe at his home late last month.

    Have your say at www.iol.co.za/opinion



      • This article was originally published on page 1 of The Star on November 10, 2009
  • Showing page 1 of 12 comment pages, 115 total comments
    1 Week ago father of 2 wrote :
    no one is above the law - not even the cops. will zuma take responsibility for the innocent blood spilled by commenting on shoot to kill?
    1 Week ago Anonymous wrote :
    This is sick and disgusting, i hope those people may suffer for the rest of their lives, and i also think that this shoot to kill sh*t is really sick, how do you shoot a three year old, you people should first go back to school cause most of your'll are uneducated your'll only have STD 8, shame on you guys, you people MAKE ME SICK DAY BY DAY!!!!!!!!! (Edited by IOL)
    1 Week ago loud wrote :
    Is this the replacement of the death penalty? Is it SHOOT to KILL or shoot to defend? Serve and kill or serve and protect?..
    1 Week ago Anonymous wrote :
    It is things like this that makes me so angry. Go and open up a case now and see the treatment that you get.I wish those policemen roth in HELLLLL for what they have done, but as I know they will get away with it.
    1 Week ago Anonymous wrote :
    This is just very very sad. I have a 3 yr old son and cannot begin to imagine what the parents must have gone through having their son's body lying on a pavement for 6 hours. Where is the respect for human life? Where is the respect for each other? I am saddened and most of all afraid that my children are being raised in such a sick and twisted society, where we cannot trust our police, where our healthcare and emergency services are in a total shambles and then off course there's the crime. Why should we have to live like this?
    1 Week ago Taylor zn wrote :
    Can anyone begin to imagine the horror that these dear parents must have gone through and still endure after this nightmarish disgrace to our South African Police Service and Country? My prayers and sincere condolences to the parents and family. I pray also for Swift Justice against the incompetent constable and also his cowboy colleagues!!!
    1 Week ago Anonymous wrote :
    To that Policeman who killed a 3 year old boy - you are sick sick sick!!! Where are the GOOD COPS - the ones you can TRUST? You took a special little soul that was pure...
    1 Week ago Anonymous wrote :
    What makes me mad is that those 2 policeman where laughing and eating lollypops like nothing happened.Can you imagine those policeman not even on uniforms or police vests showing that they were on duty guess what they were just wearing shots,sandals and caps.
    1 Week ago Jo(Protea Glen) wrote :
    The 3 year old shooting is another confirmation that the recruitment strategy for admission as an SAPS official is failing, because it seems police officials of late are getting more power hungry than community services orientated. Sadly South Africa still has so much to prove to the world that we are developing into a strong nation , yet with different goals.This really hurts.
    1 Week ago Modikwe wrote :
    I am really hurt by what our law enforcement aents are doing. They have taken the "shoot to kill" principle too far, because I suppose it was meant only when their lives are in danger. The silence of the Police Commisioner and the Ministry on all these barbaric acts by the police is also very disturbing. I hope justice will prevail and the policeman who did this can be punished appropriately. To Mapula, the father and all family members; let God Almighty be with you and give you peace.
    HAVE YOUR SAY
    Please enter your comment into the text box below.
    Note: all comments are moderated (see our moderation policy) and may take some time to display, or may not appear at all.
    If you would like to use an alias, please type it below. If you do not enter an alias you comment under a Anonymous byline.
    Type your email address below - your comment will not be accepted without it. This is required as part of our moderation guidelines, but your address will not be published or distributed.
    Lastly, to help fight spam, enter the letters in the image below as you see them.

    Email StoryPrint Story
    BOOKMARK THIS STORY
    Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

    Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

    Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

    muti



    Subscribe now to The Star

    Shattered: A single gunshot through the window of a parked car, and a three-year-old boy was dead. The alleged shooter: a police constable. Photo: Dumisani Sibeko, The Star

    Watch IOLs latest videos on YouTube Join IOLs Facebook page Follow IOL on Twitter





         Online Services

    Date Your Destiny
     
    I'm a 28 year old woman looking to meet men between the ages of 29 and 78.
     

         More Services

         More South Africa Stories