Article Search

 'Baby blind, deaf after hospital bungle'
    November 03 2009 at 07:22AM Get IOL on your
mobile at m.iol.co.za

Submit your comment

By Noor-Jehan Yoro Badat

A six-month-old baby went into a West Rand hospital to be treated for an ear infection, only to be discharged almost a month later nearly blind, and deaf in one ear.

Now a Honeydew couple are suing the Life Wilgeheuwel Hospital, claiming one of its nurses acted negligently while treating their baby.

The hospital says an investigation is under way.

'Eventually I screamed that Laila was not breathing'
Speaking exclusively to The Star, Kogie, 38, and Rodney Subramoney, 40, said they took their baby to the hospital to be treated for a severe ear infection. The child was admitted, and over a period of several days was given an intravenous antibiotic, Rocephin, through a drip and had grommets inserted.

The baby was discharged and the parents were told to bring her back to the paediatric ward on October 2 for the final dose of the antibiotic. It was then that things went wrong, said Kogie, a human resources manager.
Continues Below ↓





The couple say they told the nurse treating Laila that her drip cord was filled with blood, but she ignored their concerns. Instead, the nurse "returned with a syringe and flushed the drip without first removing the bandage and examining Laila's hand", said Kogie.

She claims she also told the nurse "there was a bubble in the syringe". Again, the nurse didn't acknowledge her concern.

Rodney, a banker, was holding Laila on his lap when the nurse began administering the antibiotic. Laila began to cry hysterically, Kogie said.

'She cannot eat properly'
Three times, she said, she and her husband asked the nurse to stop the procedure because Laila was "crying profusely, appeared to be choking and was not taking in any air".

But the nurse continued, said Kogie.

"Eventually I screamed that Laila was not breathing. The nurse finally stopped," she said.

Then, she alleged, the nurse took Laila from Rodney and "walked casually across to the procedure room with her on her hip". Her "casual reaction", Kogie said, didn't indicate that Laila "had in fact stopped breathing completely".

A doctor was attending to a patient in the procedure room, but the nurse holding Laila did not alert her, Kogie claimed.

"She walked over to a cupboard, still carrying Laila on her hip, who was hanging there limp and lifeless," said Kogie.

The nurse, she alleged, spent a few moments fiddling with the packet of an oxygen mask.

"I grabbed the packet from her, trying to tear it open. The nurse was saying in a low voice that the baby was not breathing," Kogie said.

Laila had turned a purplish grey colour and her eyes had rolled back, said Rodney.

Kogie said she screamed for someone to help her baby and said it was only then that the doctor became aware of the situation. The nurse casually held Laila up in the air and announced that the baby had stopped breathing.

"Laila was placed on the bed. Milk began to run out of her nose. The doctor checked on Laila's vital signs and we overheard her say there was no heartbeat or pulse," said Kogie.

"I screamed for them to bring her back," she said.

The doctor worked on Laila for some time before she was finally taken to intensive care and placed on life support.

"The doctor later said Laila had been dead for a period of time before being revived. Had that doctor not been in the procedure room that day, our baby would have died," said Kogie.

Laila was on life support for several days and in ICU for about three weeks, said Kogie.

In that time, Laila had a seizure and underwent a battery of tests, including two lumbar punctures.

The incident left Laila blind and deaf in one ear. She is also no longer able to hold her head up and crawl or sit, apparently as a result of a loss of oxygen that left her neck muscles weak.

"She is like a month-old baby," her distraught mother said.

"When she opened her eyes it was as if she was looking right through me," said Kogie, adding that her daughter now has to see several specialists.

Laila was discharged last week.

"She has some of her vision back, but she still cannot sit or crawl. She cannot eat properly," Kogie said.

"When I asked the hospital manager whether the nurse had been suspended, he told me that he didn't think it was fair to suspend her until they do an investigation," Rodney said.

Yesterday, the couple's lawyer, Stephen Flowers, said they were drafting a summons to be issued against the hospital.

Life Healthcare Group spokeswoman Marietjie Shelly said an internal investigation into the incident was being conducted.

"Hospital management regard this incident in a serious light," she said.

"The first assessments indicate that further investigations are needed. Nursing specialists are also involved in the investigation and assessment of the actions taken by the nursing staff who were involved."

    • This article was originally published on page 1 of The Star on November 03, 2009
Showing page 1 of 8 comment pages, 73 total comments
2 Weeks ago Dianne Farrell wrote :
Our 17 year old son died at wilgeheuwel hospital on the 16 March 2007 as a result of a doctor in the casualty department refusing to treat him because it was 18h50 and she was going off at 19h00. And then telling me she is not a doctor when she was the doctor on duty. Our son bled to death in their hospital they did not have the equipment that the surgeon needed who took him to theatre three hours after arriving in their hospital and just like this case Maritjie Shelly came up with lies and excuses in her reply to the Northside Chronicle and to date we have not heard a word about their investigation into the matter but we were harrassed for payment for their account of over R40,000.00 for 7 hours in their hospital of which two hours our child lay in their "casualty" ward not being treated. His total bills amounted to R92000.00. Maritjie shelly must hate her job always having to lie to the media because the hospital group she works for destroys lives. That hospital needs to be closed down and the staff should be jailed for their actions
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
Its about time that nurses change their bloody attitudes and work hand in hand with family members.They must respect patient as well as families.My prayers are with u . God bless.
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
It happened to me as well in 2004 it was 2 student doctors from Mowbray martenity,and i still remember the date 9 February but i don't want to talk about it, it hurts too much. I am crying even now....but my baby girl is 5 yrs old and healthy.
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
Our daughter went in to Wilgeheuwel for a routine ear operation and came out with a "theatre acquired infection" which has left her one ear deformed! Type of thing you'd expect at a really bad state hospital. And the nurses were (mostly) uncaring. Never ever again wil we entrust our family to Wilgeheuwel - Olivedale & Sandton are much more caring & professional.
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
Sue the hospital for present and future medical expenses. Don't give up the fight.
2 Weeks ago Tasneem wrote :
My daughter also had a bad experience at the same hospital. She had needles inserted into the bones in her knees without being given any pain medication. These nurses should be frired and not allowed to practice at all. Their attitude makes me sick to my stomach and what makes it worse is that they get away with it. My prayers are with Laila and her family.
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
I am so sorry for this family. A similar thing happened to us and our son died two years ago (two years after his brain was injured). We attempted to sue, but ran out of money. Doctors, hospitals and nurses get away with whatever they do because it is SOOOOO expensive to sue them in civil court.
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
My domestic worker went into labour last week, I rushed her to Johannesburg General. She was in such pain but they only attended to her hours later. At that point the doctor examined her and told her that her baby was dead. Once she gave birth to the baby the nurse threw her baby in the bin. A little while later the nurse noticed that the baby in the bin was indeed alive. She then scurried to attend to the baby. They came to apologise to her about it later. How could they not have checked the baby once it was born. This is surely not the procedure to follow. The baby was 1.5 kg at birth and is still in the High Care Unit on oxygen and intravenous drip. I found the whole experience she went through shocking, there is so much more to tell. You are most welcome to contact me for further details on 072 1366 845. (Pls do not print my cell no) Sufiya
2 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
I took my hudband to that hospital one night because he could not breath properly. The doctor just came in and said what is your problem with an attitude. And then there was a drunk and hysterical patient they did not bother to restrain. We were sent to the x-ray department and found it was locked. A horrible experience all way round.
2 Weeks ago Troy wrote :
it is sad that this has happened and i hope the parents sue the hospital, because hurting the bottom line is the only way to make sure this nurse is removed from the system
HAVE YOUR SAY
Please enter your comment into the text box below.
Note: all comments are moderated (see our moderation policy) and may take some time to display, or may not appear at all.
If you would like to use an alias, please type it below. If you do not enter an alias you comment under a Anonymous byline.
Type your email address below - your comment will not be accepted without it. This is required as part of our moderation guidelines, but your address will not be published or distributed.
Lastly, to help fight spam, enter the letters in the image below as you see them.

Email StoryPrint Story
BOOKMARK THIS STORY
Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

muti



Subscribe now to The Star

Bungle: This six-month-old baby went into a West Rand hospital to be treated for an ear infection, only to be discharged almost a month later nearly blind, and deaf in one ear. Photo: Jennifer Bruce, The Star

Watch IOLs latest videos on YouTube Join IOLs Facebook page Follow IOL on Twitter





     Online Services


Bungle: This six-month-old baby went into a West Rand hospital to be treated for an ear infection, only to be discharged almost a month later nearly blind, and deaf in one ear. Photo: Jennifer Bruce, The Star

Date Your Destiny
 
I'm a 33 year old woman looking to meet men between the ages of 32 and 42.
 

     More Services

     More South Africa Stories