Article Search

 Girl, 9, aborts twins
    March 05 2009 at 07:14AM Get IOL on your
mobile at m.iol.co.za

Rio de Janeiro - A nine-year-old girl who was carrying twins, allegedly after being raped by her stepfather, underwent an abortion on Wednesday despite complaints from Brazil's Roman Catholic church.

Abortion is illegal in Brazil, but exceptions can be made if the mother's life is in danger or the foetus has no chance of survival.

Fatima Maia, the director of the hospital where the abortion was performed, said the pregnancy had posed a serious risk to the 36kg girl.

"She is very small. Her uterus doesn't have the ability to hold one, let alone two children," Maia said.

But Marcio Miranda, a lawyer for the church, said the girl should have carried the babies to term and had a Caesarean section.
Continues Below ↓





Brazil is home to more Catholics than any other nation. - Sapa-AP

    • This article was originally published on page 2 of Cape Times on March 05, 2009
Showing page 1 of 3 comment pages, 22 total comments
37 Weeks ago Christian wrote :
Its tragic what has happened to the raped 9 year old girl and the murdered (aborted) twins. Its good to know the man was arrested and i believe justice shall happen. It's not fair/right/good to have killed the twins for the crime of the father. The Church has a role to preserve life not kill. So shame on those who can't respect life in any form.
37 Weeks ago anonymous wrote :
This is such a sad story. If it was my daughter i would kill the animal who did it to her first and then deal with the pregnancy or the abortion
37 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
the DEVIL is like a hungary lion, looking to see wher he can get his pray
37 Weeks ago Dennis A. Y. wrote :
So much had been said so furiously against the Catholic Church, but I think She just spoke what is morally right in the eyes of God,yes the act of the stepdad is worth condemning,and so is rape,and so are the pedophiles,and all those acts done against women.The child had undergone so much trauma, I sympathize, I would imagine,if the same thing happens to my daughter(not the incestous rape,God forbid)awkward pregnancy.Still I wount resort to abortion(with exception of ectopic pregnancy and anencephaly,or fetus with no cranial bone)Yes the Roman Catholic Church is correct that she should have had preserved the Life,a wrong doing cannot be corrected by doing another wrong.If the child is given all the proper support, care, and counselling,there could be a good chance that she will make it through the pregnancy.Those who had said that abortion is the best solution dont have real Faith in God, they are so concerned about the earthly life and comfort.When God asked Abraham to kill his son Isaac as offering to Him,all those who cursed the Catholic Church for Her opposition to the abortion may curse God as well for asking a well abled life as an offering to Him which seems like doesn't show any sense at all but Real Faith in God's wisdom. They hated The Church because She choosed Life at all cost, but nobody questioned God why He asked Abraham's son as an offering, dont get confused, both situations asks for unconditional Faith in God,if God wills it, the Child will live and so are the twins, with all the support, at the end of the day,we could say,weve done our part as God's people. I think God will not say you people should have done the right thing,you should have had killed the twins at the start if you dont like it.Or do you think God will blame you because you allowed the pregnancy, and blame you of the child's death and of the foetuses, but if we have real Faith and put everything in God's hands,if He wills it,the child will live and so are the twins.Dont hate the Church for speaking for what is morally right,yes there maybe so many immorals and hypocrites in the Church,they are just humans and sinners as well, but look at the teachings of the Church, not the sins of the people in Her, She conveys what is of God.Dont treat pregnancy as if it is a cyst, there is Life in it like ours.Peace...
37 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
Catholic church still in the dark ages and have no sense of the real world. I myself also am not religious because of cr@p like this. So much blood have been shed because of religion...it is causing more damage than doing good. Pope sitting in his gold adorned Vatican city...funded by some of the poorest countries?! Shocking. It is high time that the church be cut down to size. I say follow the 10 commandments, as these are based on common sense...the rest is used to inflame hatred and discrimmination against gay people, women etc. How the religions of the world still manages to do harm like this in the 21st century is beyond me. I applaud the doctors who did this for this innocent child. And as for the stepfather....IF ONLY IT WAS POSSIBLE TO IMPREGNATE HIM WITH QUADS AND LET HIM GIVE BIRTH AND SEE HOW HE LIKES IT!
37 Weeks ago Rabs. wrote :
Marcio! or whatever the name is...just plain stupid,im sure she doesnt have a daughter herself....i mean if you are a mother of 9 how can you say and expect such things from another 9 year old gal? I hope you get to read this...YOU DISGUST ME and im sure the rest of the world agrees with me.
37 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
So how many Hail Mary's for this offence? It's bad enough the Catholic church covers for their paedophilic priests.
37 Weeks ago charlene wrote :
I agree the church is wrong in this instance. She is just a little girl and being a mother myself and giving birth to a 4,5kg baby wasn't easy for me, let alone a nine year old. Shame on you Marcia Miranda. The stepfather should pay for what he did to the child.
37 Weeks ago Disgusted wrote :
Ridiculous! So she went through the trauma of being raped, bearing the psychological scars of this forever, now she should carry twins full term, be subjected to all the emotions and physical symptoms of a pregnancy and then still have to endure a caesarian and the pain and after-effects of this operation? Bearing in mind she was a sweet innocent child who didn't ask for this... Will anyone in their right minds want their daughter to endure this suffering? No, I think not! I agree that abortion is not moral, but we need to be open-minded when it comes to situations like these. Things aren't always black and white. We need to consider the personal circumstances of each case.
37 Weeks ago Mohammed wrote :
What is happening in the world today? 9 year olds getting raped by the same people who are supposed to protect them. How is the 9 year old supposed to deal with trauma of this nature? I feel her so sorry. What is the world coming to? We have become barabaric and uncivilised without a doubt.

Email StoryPrint Story
BOOKMARK THIS STORY
Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

muti



Subscribe now to Cape Times
Watch IOLs latest videos on YouTube Join IOLs Facebook page Follow IOL on Twitter





     Online Services

     More Services

     More South America Stories

     Breaking News      Most Read Stories
      Top News Stories
      Top World Stories
      Top Reads - Yesterday



     Entertainment      Motoring
'Twenty-five years feels right in my bones'
Radio station in a knot over wedding dilemma
Driver dies in Miley Cyrus tour bus crash

     Business
Obama touts Asia trade to create jobs
Michelin to build new factory in Brazil
Thousands of Spanish farmers protest low prices
Well-mannered Porsche - just built to race
Kia's latest baby - she's even smaller than a Picanto
Communist cousins in demand from behind the Wall
Amid Expo back in 2010 despite poor sales
Triumph recalls Sprint 1050 ST

     Travel
Berlin hipster hotel taps bygone spirit
River Plate reflect on the past
Still hope for the Garden Route
Marrying great music with fine food
Beaujolais nouveau hot in Japan
     Careers
For many, full potential goes unharnessed
Getting to grips with the transport industry
To be your own boss, believe in yourself first
Salary survey puts unstable economy into the equation
Development of child is key