Article Search

 The new face of poverty
    October 15 2009 at 07:04AM Get IOL on your
mobile at m.iol.co.za

By Omeshnie Naidoo

'If you are white and you're poor in this country, you must be stupid," comedian Mark Banks joked recently, referring to the opportunities created specifically for all white South Africans during apartheid.

Didn't white beggars take advantage of all those years of apartheid, Banks insinuates.

Ken Johnson clearly did not. The 59-year-old was born on Durban's Berea to a father who worked as a tiler and a mother who stayed at home.

The most defining moment in his life was when his parents divorced. Turned out by his stepfather, Johnson took to drinking. With only a Std 6 education he found work at a security company.
Continues Below ↓





Johnson's own marriage ended in separation. He doesn't know where his four children are; he only points to the street corner where his estranged wife, like him, begs from strangers most days.

Johnson occasionally finds work, but they are just "odds and ends", he says, although years ago he worked as a railway yard official in Germiston where he lived in a railway house.

Like him, Johnson's friend, 54-year-old Dave Campbell, worked for Eskom and lived in a government house. Campbell used to drive buses and trucks and was a soccer player in his heyday. Now he begs on street corners to survive every day.

Also begging on the streets of Berea, but far less talkative is 59-year-old John Bell, who used to be a customs officer at Durban Harbour before he was medically boarded. He says his mother and sister live in a flat on the Berea, but won't tolerate his smoking. There's no room for him anyway, he adds.

How did these men, all who had held down jobs and had roofs over their heads at some stage in the lives, end up on the streets? How did they miss out on the job creation and house reservation programmes to deal with the "poor white" problem which was implemented well before apartheid became official.

The ability to find employment and the availability of jobs was then, and remains now, at the core of the dilemma. "How do I find a job," asks 24-year-old Pretoria-born Lyle Volker.

"I don't even smell like someone who should be waiting on people and serving them food."

Costa Kaidatzis, who regularly brings food to Volker and the others begging on the Berea, says finding employment is difficult but more so in these tough economic times.

Together with the help of Durban's St Olav Church in Musgrave, Kaidatzis helps reunite the homeless with their families and find employment. Kaidatzis, whose dream is to create a facility where the homeless can have showers, receive medical attention and have access to sheltered employment and accommodation, says there are about 10 000 homeless people between Berea and the beachfront.

Dr David Hemson, at the Human Sciences Research Council in Durban, says the government should also take responsibility through expanded public works, similar to what occurred in the US in the 1930s when poverty was alleviated through President Franklin Rooseveldt's New Deal which created jobs through various projects, from dams to road developments.

"You cannot look at today's circumstances without contextualising it within the current economic climate. The recession and economic crisis play a significant role," he says. "While some people may have had advantages in the past it is clear we are all affected by the recession and changed socio-political circumstances - no one is immune."

On the streets it's not about whether you were advantaged or whether you're black or white, says Volker. If anything, he says he feels alienated from the white community who don't want to see poor whites like him. "For those with money it is to an extent about not wanting to 'see'," he says.

Drum magazine writer Bloke Modisane, in his autobiography Blame Me on History, dwells on an encounter with a white "hobo", commenting on the poverty they share and therefore the common humanity they are locked into.

The white hobo, he writes, represents a "crack in the myth of white supremacy".

A similar story is covered in a novel recently published by Kwela Books, Small Moving Parts. The author, Sally-Ann Murray, explains that the narrative deals with a white working-class Durban family, and tries to show the fractures that existed even during apartheid's era of white privilege.

"As South Africans we're understandably prone to see life in black and white since our history has made us incredibly conscious of race," Murray says.

"But even whiteness is never homogeneous. We forget, given the Big Story of white privilege, that there are always complexities; that perhaps not all whites were wealthy," she says.

The idea of false dichotomy or black-and-white-thinking that she refers to is the same lenses through which Banks's joke was made. "It makes it easier for us to assume we've heard the red-faced woman at the robot's story before so we can turn a deaf ear, or blind ourselves to her hidden story," says Murray.

What apartheid did to black people, according to Modisane, was to savage human beings, to dehumanise them before exterminating them. Have we as a society simply transposed that thinking to the poor of today; black and white?


Rise and fall of poor whites

According to The History of Southern Africa by JD Omer-Cooper, the 1920s marked the pauperisation of the white Afrikaans community.

At this time the mining industry had opened up increased opportunities for commercial farming so landlords seeking to make more profitable use of their land evicted their white tenants. Capitalised farming and fixed boundaries also prevented the acquisition of land. This affected the lifestyles of the Boer farmers who, despite being landless, continued to have large families.

They trekked to the towns; however, the majority of these poor whites lacked the skills necessary for mining and as Afrikaans-speakers found themselves further handicapped in urban environments dominated by English-speakers.

Their experiences led to the 1924 alliance election win between the Labour Party, which represented mainly white workers, and Hertzog's National Party, which largely represented the Afrikaner farmers.

This government established the Iron and Steel Corporation (Iscor) in 1928 as well as a range of secondary industries, increasing employment opportunities for whites, and introduced a programme of racial segregation.

In state controlled enterprises, particularly the railways, black workers were simply displaced to provide jobs for whites.

Private industry was persuaded to employ a high portion of whites, since tariff protection was dependent on the industry following satisfactory labour policies.

To legalise the reservation of skilled jobs for whites on the mines, a Mines and Works Amendment Act was passed in 1926 which specifically prohibited the employment of Africans and Asians in skilled work.

From this point it looked as though the poor white problem had been adequately dealt with.

According to this book, the problem resurfaced in the 1990s when, after years of apartheid, segregation and its laws were removed. The government repealed The Separate Amenities Act, Group Areas Act and Registration Act which was essentially the removal of racial privilege. During this time it was reported that 20 000 whites were being fed by hunger relief agencies.

    • This article was originally published on page 14 of The Mercury on October 15, 2009
Showing page 1 of 3 comment pages, 22 total comments
9 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
This is absolute rubbish. My interpretation of this article, particularly the last paragraph is that the reason for white beggars is the end of apartheid and attempts to create equal opportunities.

If you had to rely on government to make it easy for you to get by and make a living, and cannot do that without the suppression of a people on your side, then you have only yourself to blame for your failures.

I also understand the lack of commaraderie amongst white people, i.e. the rich whites not giving to the poor whites. Life isn't about begging and receiving. No one is responsible for your well-being but you. Stop asking for a hand out and do something to make your life better!
9 Weeks ago S. Kearney wrote :
@all i agree with you.I'm a white 27 year old educated male and feeling the effects of affirmative action (It's not easy anymore) but hey, I still make a good living. These people on the streets are people who gave up on life for be it any reason. This country still have so much oppertunities for all. Thats is what a developing country provides, oppertunity!
9 Weeks ago @all wrote :
Honestly, i couldn’t give a damn about white beggars... I sit in an office full of white people who all drive expensive cars and make lots of money, why the hell aren’t they helping other whites. To top it off all i see on these forums is complaints about how ill treated whites are in this country meanwhile they are in the highest income bracket. This is not a phenomenon that only happens in our country, in every country where there is freedom for all and free markets some must suffer black or white...
9 Weeks ago Freedomfighter wrote :
With so many unemployed people in our country, how on earth can we possibly justify the minumum wage laws? In a first world country these laws serve to ensure that low wage earners get a decent amount of money. But these countries have extremely low unemployment and very large and vibrant private sectors, so jobs are plentiful in any case. In third world countries (yes we are a poor third world country) these same mimum wage laws only serve to ensure that the poorest of the poor cannot and do not get jobs. It's the same as saying to them - if you cannot find a job where you can earn at least R856 per month (rural domestic worker) then you are not allowed to feed yourself and your family, we do not care that you are prepared to work for less. If someone gives you a job for less than that we will put them in jail. South Africa is rife with legislation copied from first world - mostly European countries - and forced onto a third world environment where it simply does not fit and is causing massive harm.
9 Weeks ago Leslie Mashishi wrote :
I agree with most comments. All of us are affected. But begging on street corrners is not going to change their lives. I have friends who sell on street corners, taxi ranks and so on and they are making a leaving. Their children can afford to wear nice clothes, go to school and so on. Have these white beggars attempted to register for Government's low cost housing? I don't think so. The problem is that they can't be reduced to leaving in a three roomed house. Tough for them. The Government has an expanded public works programme, but can white people go and work in trenches and clean streets and collect rubbish bins? I don't think so.Maybe only a few but the majority have their pride at stake. I know of a few who are petrol attendants, waiters and so on but at least they survive. In this trying times, the issue should not be about white or black, but about how we as a nation survive.If these white people who used to work and have roofs over their heads can go look themselves in the mirror and decide to be positive about the future, they can change their own situations. I know because my father used to work for the then City Council of Pretoria, still managed to put food on the table even after he stopped working. We were never homeless and we did not beg on the streets. We lived in a shack and we were all happy until we manage to build ourselves a six roomed house. We did not leave in a government house but here we are today still surviving. I don't feel sorry for beggars, black or white. People must pick themselves up and survive.
9 Weeks ago Patrick wrote :
To all the smug white and black people, there for the grace of God go I. Most South Africans will be standing at the Traffic lights if they are unemployed for a period of three months. So let us not cast any stones !
9 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
Isn't it funny how Apartheid is suddenly always spoken of as having been all about "white privalage and opportunity"! Well I happened to be around during Apartheid and I remember it as having been a period of choice and opportunity for the Nguni and Sotho Peoples: they had the choice of free land and a culturally distinct rural lifestyle, or the opportunity for many to work in the de-centralised industries, while still more (like Nelson Mandela) could attend further education in their own homeland and then practice their profession within the Republic of South Africa if they chose to leave their homeland!
My point is, before we all go shooting our mouths off about a view of history that is subjective, let me rid the New South Africa of its "poor white problem" for you: just give me an area of South Africa with the same carying capacity as Zululand or the Transkei in the '60s and I will take every "white squatter and beggar" off your hands and house them in said area where, just as wih the "Homelands" of the Apartheid Period, ALL LAND, ALL JOBS, AND ALL LOCAL GOVERNMENT POSTS WILL BE RESERVED FOR THOSE LIVING THERE!
Fair is fair!
9 Weeks ago Ryno wrote :
"Didn't white beggars take advantage of all those years of apartheid, Banks insinuate" So during apartheid all whites were offered jobs as doctors and lawyers, I dont think so. Unlike today, people had to study and work for what they wanted. If you could not afford to study you worked for the state, police etc. Yes, as a white you got into the public service much easier, but the notion to think that all whites had jobs and a jolly good time in the past is rubbish
9 Weeks ago Bain wrote :
Ian

They won't get jobs by standing around all day begging. Let them take a tip from the black entrepeneurs who share their pitch and at least buy something to sell.
9 Weeks ago Ian wrote :
A persons self esteem is destroyed when they lose a job so assuming they must just go out and get a job is sometimes not that easy. I agree that that is what they should do but these people need to be rehabilitated back into society. Until you have walked in their shoes do not be so judgemental. Also the economy is not growing sufficiently to absorb all newcomers to the market and those that have lost their jobs.

Email StoryPrint Story
BOOKMARK THIS STORY
Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

muti



Subscribe now to The Mercury
Watch IOLs latest videos on YouTube Join IOLs Facebook page Follow IOL on Twitter





     Online Services

Date Your Destiny
 
I'm a 21 year old woman looking to meet men between the ages of 18 and 100.
 

     More Services

     More Opinion Stories