Article Search

 Mabandla 'not evading court clash'
    May 11 2008 at 12:21PM Get IOL on your
mobile at m.iol.co.za

By Karyn Maughan and Boyd Webb

Brigitte Mabandla, the justice minister, does not believe that her refusal to testify against Vusi Pikoli, the suspended national prosecutions head, should be held against her.

In an interview on Saturday, Zolile Nqayi, Mabandla's spokesperson, insisted that the minister chose not to take the stand against Pikoli because she believed her evidence "would add nothing" to the Ginwala Commission's inquiry into his fitness to hold office.

Mabandla had tried to stop Pikoli from arresting Jackie Selebi, the national police commissioner.

Asked if the prospect of being cross-examined about the events surrounding Pikoli's suspension - which Pikoli maintains was motivated solely by the government's desperate bid to protect Selebi - had played any part in Mabandla's decision not to testify, Nqayi was adamant: "No, it was not even a consideration."
Continues Below ↓





"The minister has supplied the [commission] with extensive written submissions and responded to every claim made against her by Mr Pikoli. She has also answered the questions asked her by the [commission]. There is no need for her to give evidence."

Though refusing to comment directly on Mabandla's absence from the government's list of witnesses, Frene Ginwala, the head of the commission, has made it clear that "any contested evidence to which there has been no response may attract a finding that the party not contesting that evidence accepts the correctness of that evidence".

Under normal rules of evidence, this would mean that Mabandla's failure to challenge Pikoli's testimony with her own will lead the commission to give more weight to Pikoli's version of the events surrounding his suspension.

Menzi Simelane, the director-general of the department of justice, this week admitted, under cross-examination by Wim Trengove, Pikoli's advocate, that he could not explain the circumstances under which Mabandla asked Pikoli to resign about two weeks after the Scorpions obtained arrest and search warrants against Selebi.

Questioning Simelane about the day President Thabo Mbeki suspended Pikoli, Trengove asked: "Do you know what the minster said to Mr Pikoli [that] Sunday at 5pm?"

"No," said Simelane.

"She said 'I want you to resign'. Did you not know that?"

"No. I don't know if that's what she said to him. As I said, I wasn't there," Simelane responded.

"Without taking up [Pikoli's] repeated offers to provide her with whatever other information she might require [about the case against Selebi], she concluded that he had to go," Trengrove said.

"If that's what she concluded …," Simelane said.

"Can you explain it?" Trengrove interjected.

Simelane's voice trailed off: "I can't explain it, so I'm not going to."

Simelane also failed to answer questions about whether it was he or Mabandla who had decided to deny the existence of a letter sent by Mbeki to Mabandla the day before she ordered Pikoli not to arrest Selebi.

He was also forced to admit that a statement he made under oath, in which he denied that the government interfered with Pikoli's "decisions to investigate and prosecute any person", was not true.

Pikoli's legal team has argued that Mabandla's "improper interference" in the state's case against Selebi amounted to a criminal offence.


Email StoryPrint Story
BOOKMARK THIS STORY
Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

muti



Subscribe now to Sunday Independent
     Related Articles
More Politics stories

Watch IOLs latest videos on YouTube Join IOLs Facebook page Follow IOL on Twitter





     Online Services

Date Your Destiny
 
I'm a 32 year old woman looking to meet men between the ages of 33 and 40.
 

     More Services

     More Politics Stories

     Breaking News      Most Read Stories
      Top News Stories
      Top South Africa Stories
      Top Reads - Yesterday



     Entertainment      Motoring
'Twenty-five years feels right in my bones'
Radio station in a knot over wedding dilemma
Driver dies in Miley Cyrus tour bus crash

     Business
Obama touts Asia trade to create jobs
Michelin to build new factory in Brazil
Thousands of Spanish farmers protest low prices
Well-mannered Porsche - just built to race
Kia's latest baby - she's even smaller than a Picanto
Communist cousins in demand from behind the Wall
Amid Expo back in 2010 despite poor sales
Triumph recalls Sprint 1050 ST

     Travel
Berlin hipster hotel taps bygone spirit
River Plate reflect on the past
Still hope for the Garden Route
Marrying great music with fine food
Beaujolais nouveau hot in Japan
     Careers
For many, full potential goes unharnessed
Getting to grips with the transport industry
To be your own boss, believe in yourself first
Salary survey puts unstable economy into the equation
Development of child is key