Am I too prudish for my new lover?

Comment on this story
sharon-stone-david-morrissey-basic-instinct-2-dry-hair-movie-poster . Who can forget Sharon Stone's seduction game in the Basic Instinct films?

QUESTION: I met my partner through mutual friends after my divorce and we’ve been together for almost a year. My teenage children like him and we are well matched in most ways, as we share a lot of interests and both run our own companies. However, I am unsettled by some of the things he asks me to do. He has suggested on a couple of occasions that I “wear no undies” to a party we’re both attending, and when we’re on the phone he likes me to describe what underwear I’m wearing. I feel uncomfortable with his requests, but don’t want to come across as a spoilsport.

ANSWER: I understand your anxiety: your new man has clearly taken you out of your comfort zone. You were married for some time and presumably became used to living with a man who expressed no overt interest in your lingerie or lack of it.

When you start dating after a long while in a stable relationship, any unfamiliarity in courtship style can trigger alarm. I had one friend who was even suspicious of a new boyfriend who gave her a rose on every date (her former husband had never given her flowers). She said to me: “Isn’t that a bit creepy and stalker-ish?”

If your partner’s risque behaviour is limited to this fixation on the state of your underpinnings, then I don’t think you need panic. It sounds as if he’s just bolder than most men about stating a commonly-held fantasy. I would say that about 80 percent of straight men get hot under the collar when thinking of a woman - particularly an ostensibly prim one - going out without her knickers.

It’s hard for women to grasp the lure of this fantasy because we don’t want men to tell us about their underpants; nor do we fantasise about them going commando underneath their pin-striped suit.

What you must understand about men is that their erotic imagination is transfixed by the notion of a woman wearing nothing beneath a skirt or dress (believe you me, this fantasy does not work with trousers) because it suggests a tantalising frisson of availability.

Then there’s the thrilling thought for your partner that in a busy social setting you and he share a very intimate secret.

Lastly, I expect he hopes that your knicker-less state will increase the likelihood that you’ll have sex after the party.

His telephone inquiries about your lingerie spring from a similarly widespread male fantasy. For some reason, many men like to think that women tend to lounge around the house in black suspenders, silk stockings and push-up brassieres.

I see no reason to disillusion them on this matter. All’s fair in love and war, so there’s nothing dishonourable about describing your La Perla silk slip over the phone, while actually sitting watching TV in thermal pyjamas.

What you have to remember is that your boyfriend’s query about your undies is a happy daydream, rather than an instruction. It’s a flirty conversation, not an exercise in truth-telling.

How comfortable you feel in playing along will depend on whether you are a fictionalist or a literalist. Few arty types have problems engaging in this kind of imaginative exchange, but those of a more rational, scientific bent can find it hard to indulge in fantasy.

I have one friend - a writer in her 40s - whose partner of a year is always phoning her to ask: “Are you wearing stockings?” She always says “Yes”, as she wants to maintain the illusion of being a stockings- and no-knickers girl for him, but since she lives in a house with no central heating, she’s usually in woolly tights.

She says that the small deception is harmless: “It’s like telling a child there is a tooth fairy. Why break the spell if it makes them so happy? Everyone crashes into grim reality eventually.”

As she rightly point outs, this is the kind of fantasy that couples enjoy in the early years, and it’s generally dependent on living apart. Once you’re in the same house, the magnetic allure of your underwear drawer will be diminished.

If it really is beyond your ken to play along with your partner’s fantasies, then you will simply have to tell him how uncomfortable you feel. You could, perhaps, compare your ordeal to that of your typical British man being asked to talk about his feelings. Most of the males I know find it as gruelling to talk about their emotions as many women find it to talk about sex.

That doesn’t mean that both genders can’t strive a little to open up and be tolerant of each other’s proclivities. In the best relationships, both partners are kind about each other’s needs - within reason.

If this man shares your interests and is liked by your children, you already have an abundance of riches; a minor obsession with your undies seems like a small irritation.

Asking your lover about her lingerie is well within the bounds of normal fantasy: you need only panic if he asks strangers about their knickers. - Daily Mail

Get our free Lifestyle newsletter - subscribe here...

sign up

Comment Guidelines

  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.

  5. Verified email addresses: All users on Independent Media news sites are now required to have a verified email address before being allowed to comment on articles. You are only required to verify your email address once to have full access to commenting on articles. For more information please read our comment guidelines 

Hameed, wrote

IOL Comments
03:20pm on 29 July 2011
IOL Comments

He is thinking one way, you should to stop him because if you do not stop this time he will ask you for something more stranger thing that you not comfortable with, but do not stop him ruddy or hardly, do it like: honey ! i would like to do this but i am feeling very uncomfortable, i'll try another time. and then after some days time tell him: i was tried to be habitual with this experiment, but unfortunately ...... now you can convince him with beautiful way. god bless you.

Report this

IOL Comments, wrote

IOL Comments
09:41am on 26 July 2011
IOL Comments

lingerieknickerspanties..u should see my collection,i keep them each time i make love to some one different

Report this

IOL Comments

Reg Grundy, wrote

IOL Comments
09:28am on 26 July 2011
IOL Comments

Just wait till he gets the butt plug out

Report this

IOL Comments

Male, wrote

IOL Comments
09:15am on 26 July 2011
IOL Comments

Here is a way to put it in a context that women may understand... Imagine you say to your self in the morning that you could really do with some chocolate. Then for the rest of the day you fantasise about eating a whole jar of Nutella or eating a box of Lindt and the list goes on! By the time the evening comes if you don't get some chocolate (NO MATTER WHAT STATE IT IS IN!) you're gonna be dangerous to be around until you get some!! The same applies to the male of the species. They start with a thought, fantasise the whole day and by the evening they are ravenous and will take you no matter what state you are in. And let me emphasise this, guys generally are not as critical of how you look as you and your female compatriots are! "So rule of thumb" applies, if it is not hurting anyone that is of sound mind and judgement and above legal age, then it is probably OK.

Report this

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 4 of 4