Cyclist wins battle over pothole injury

Comment on this story
NM Bikewin 1 INLSA Cyclist Ian Vowles points out the spot where he hit a giant pothole in Kings Road, Westville, Durban four years ago. Picture: Zanele Zulu.

Businessman Ian Vowles was a keen, competitive cyclist until one morning four years ago when he hit a giant pothole while cycling with friends.

Two weeks later, he emerged from a coma and it took months for him to recover from some of his injuries. To this day he remembers nothing of the events of the early hours of April 15, 2008, in Kings Avenue, Westville.

This week, after initially putting up a fight, the eThekwini municipality accepted liability for the accident and, in a settlement made an order of court, it agreed to pay 65 percent of his damages, including past and future medical expenses, loss of earnings, and for pain and suffering.

Papers before Durban High Court Judge Gregory Kruger quote a figure of about R4 million, but experts’ reports will still be obtained to get a final amount.

The case adds to a growing list of similar matters in which cyclists and motorcyclists have successfully sued authorities for accidents and injuries resulting from poor road maintenance.

Last year, The Mercury reported that the municipality had agreed to pay biker Scott Taylor, who was left paralysed following an accident 21 years ago when his bike hit a pothole.

And, in 2008, the Supreme Court of Appeal ordered the provincial government to pay Pietermaritzburg advocate Alistair McIntosh, who was also injured in a pothole accident while cycling.

Vowles, now 64, said the municipality had a duty to inspect and maintain roads.

It had been negligent in not properly inspecting the road, allowing the pothole to form, and in not repairing it or at least putting up signs warning road users of the hole.

According to statements from friends he was riding with early that morning, Vowles was a little ahead of the pack.

“All of a sudden Ian was thrown over his handlebars and landed on the road surface,” said Derek Davies.

Donald Allison said Vowles was wearing a helmet and had his lights on, and the street lights were on.

“I rode there regularly and was aware of the hole. Ian may not have been aware of the extent of it or that it was there at all,” he said.

“I saw Ian fall and I remember thinking we should get him up and get going. My impression was it was not very serious. But when I got there, Ian was very still. I tried to wake him up and realised he was unconscious. And we called for help.”

Apart from the fractured skull and frontal lobe damage, Vowles also had severe facial and neck injuries.

He remained in hospital for a month and received psychiatric care.

Speaking to The Mercury, Vowles said he had been the general manager of a packaging company, and the accident had been “the main motivating factor” in his decision to retire three years early.

He still cycles.

“I am not particularly nervous. I think it’s because I don’t remember anything of what happened. I was unconscious for two weeks, but it was three weeks before I really started to come round.”

He considers himself very lucky.

To keep himself busy after his retirement, he has become the manager of the charity Headway, which deals with acquired brain injuries.

He comes face to face with people who have had strokes, been assaulted and had accidents such as himself. “I see how I could have been… I took the municipality to court on a matter of principle. I don’t want this to happen to somebody else,” he said. - The Mercury

 *E-mail Tania: [email protected]

sign up

Comment Guidelines

  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.

  5. Verified email addresses: All users on Independent Media news sites are now required to have a verified email address before being allowed to comment on articles. You are only required to verify your email address once to have full access to commenting on articles. For more information please read our comment guidelines 

Sechaba, wrote

IOL Comments
09:47am on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

Every cyclist, motorcyclist and motorist who have been adversely affected by the poor roads, need to put in their claim. The government has not maintained the roads at all, everything is falling apart, and yet the tax payers money is going into their own pockets. The Health Department is a circus. Billions of lawsuits for gross negligence, thats become the order of the day!!! Why should motorists pay for wheel alignment and replacement mags when they hit a pothole and damage their tyres...? Give the government work to do as they clearly are not doing much... they also need to learn the word ACCOUNTABLE.

Report this

IOL Comments

Tshepo, wrote

IOL Comments
09:28am on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

The mayor should deal with the people responsible for fixing or not foxing the roads. What could have costs less to fix the pothole has now amounted to R4m in lawsuit which could have been spent on service delivery.

Report this

IOL Comments

lion, wrote

IOL Comments
09:12am on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

Land Reform,Education,Health,Justice,Crime, Name changing and Potholes.Nothing works!!!

Report this

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 3 of 3