Johannesburg - Jan Pieterse might not spend another day behind bars despite being convicted of dousing his lover in acid
On Tuesday, he was convicted of the lesser crime of assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm, rather than attempted murder, which the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) had tried to have him convicted of.
His former partner, Ines Antonio, has undergone six operations since November – and endured a life of unimaginable pain, unable to sleep lying down, unable to shower, dress or even eat properly because she can’t chew her food anymore. Most nights the pain keeps her awake.
On Tuesday, all she could do was express her disappointment. “He threatened me. Stalked me for months. He told me he was going to do it. Domestic violence is not taken seriously in this country.
“I have to live for the rest of my life with my disfigurement and he might get off with a light sentence,” she said.
Antonio is terrified that Pieterse, 45, might not spend a day in jail for his sentence, despite having been remanded in custody ever since he attacked her.
Phindi Louw, the NPA’s regional spokeswoman, echoed Antonio’s sentiments at an impromptu media briefing after Pieterse’s conviction.
“We are very disappointed. Domestic violence is widespread. We believe the court had a duty to protect women and it should have gone the extra mile in this case to set a precedent and to develop the law for victims,” she said.
The Director of Public Prosecutions, she said, would study the judgment to decide whether to take it on appeal for a conviction on the more serious charge.
Prosecutor Tshepo Ka Mzizi told The Star he was disappointed too. He said he would be urging the magistrate to jail Pieterse.
During recess, he appealed to Antonio to try to find it in her heart to forgive the accused, so she could move on with her life. Antonio said she could only move on when she knew that Pieterse would be behind bars for a long time.
In passing judgment, magistrate Albertus Roux took exception to Antonio’s evidence, saying she had also sent Pieterse abusive text messages after the attack.
He said Antonio’s new partner had also taken part in the abusive messages and threats. Roux said the court believed Antonio had arranged to meet Pieterse on the night of the attack.
In his testimony, Pieterse claimed he had acted in self-defence after Antonio had slapped him. Roux said this was an unreasonable act of ‘self-defence’ as Antonio was smaller than him and a woman.
“Although the fact that there was an argument seems plausible, as this was a stormy relationship, the argument, which was over visiting rights of their daughter, was trivial, so it was uncalled for to throw acid at her,” he said.
So too, if this had been a “terrible accident”, as Pieterse described the incident when testifying, why did he not show concern and compassion after the event and enquire about her injuries, he added.
Roux said it was highly unlikely that Pieterse had grabbed a tin from his boot not knowing what was in it. “This required a lot of planning,” he said, adding that throwing a tin with its lid on was unlikely to have caused as much damage as the acid did.
Pieterse had a history of abuse against Antonio, evident from the protection order she had against him, the magistrate said.
In his text messages to her after the attack, Pieterse said she had deserved what had happened to her, and that now that she was scarred, she would no longer be attractive to other men.
“The court is convinced beyond reasonable doubt that he had foreseen the injuries,” Roux said.
Dismissing the attempted murder charge, the magistrate said the State had failed to prove that Pieterse had intent to kill Antonio.
He dismissed the attempted murder charge for the injuries to their child, saying the child could have sustained minor acid burns through contact with her mother.
Pieterse is due to be sentenced on December 7.
“Ines touched my heart,” says The Star’s reporter Anna Cox.
From the moment the call came in, my heart went out to Ines Antonio.
From the hospital where she was recovering, she sent me her photo before the attack. I saw a beautiful, well-groomed young woman in the prime of her life.
In the space of seconds, her life had been ruined.
Disfigured for life, her only crime had been to want to break free from her boyfriend and the father of her child.
She was writing her matric exams at the time, in a bid to create a better life for herself and her daughter.
She said that for weeks afterwards, the police claimed they couldn’t find Jan Pieterse. The Star printed his photo on page 1, and a private investigator offered to find him free of charge.
A woman immediately recognised him and called me. I put her in touch with the private investigator, who found him within hours and arrested him with the help of the police.
On Tuesday, 11 months after the attack, Pieterse was finally convicted.
The Star
* E-mail your opinion to [email protected] and we will consider it for publication or use our Facebook and Twitter pages to comment on our stories. See links below.