Road rage

All the news about the e-tolling saga...

Debate turns into mud-slinging match

Comment on this story


ct Robin Carlisle_0307 feb 22

INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS

Transport and Public Works MEC Robin Carlisle accused the ANC of looting the provinces assets. Photo: Candice Chaplin

The ANC used the debate on Premier Helen Zille’s State of the Province address to tear into the DA and its policies as members of both parties accused each other of racism.

Attacking the theme of Zille’s opening address, ANC caucus leader Lynne Brown said that “Better Together” was contrary to the actions of the DA in government.

In her speech last week Zille highlighted her government’s achievements and future plans including:

l The establishment of an Economic Development Partnership on April 1.

l Plans to have each household in Khayelitsha and Mitchells Plain connected to broadband internet by 2014.

l Rigorously embracing an oversight role for the police through the Western Cape Community Safety Bill.

ct Lynne Brown Crop_9502 feb 22

ANC caucus leader Lynne Brown attacked the DAs racist attitude. Photo: Candice Chaplin

INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS

But Brown cited the closure of the Provincial Development Council, Zille’s twitter spats with singer Simphiwe Dana, and the police’s attitude towards protesters in Hangberg, Makhaza and Rondebosch Common as a true portrayal of the DA’s attitude to the lesser privileged.

And instead of transforming the province’s historic inequalities, Brown accused Zille and her government of maintaining the status quo.

“Access to power and the economy should still only be left in the hands of big, white business, at the exclusion of blacks and coloured people,” said Brown.

The DA government had stated that it would focus on creating jobs in established businesses.

In his response Health MEC Theuns Botha, the Leader of Government Business, said the DA had inherited “a fragmented, divided government” when it took over from the ANC in 2009.

“Now we see a slow integration of programmes resulting in less fragmentation, improved service delivery and less duplication and triplication of financial and human resources. The transversal management system proves – we are indeed Better Together,” said Botha.

Using the example of Limpopo, Botha said financial mismanagement was only uncovered due to internal strife within the party and that there were more dysfunctional departments in other provinces.

Responding to comments and asides from the opposition benches, Botha said that despite the Western Cape being “a horrible” place, according to members of the ANC many people still came to live in the province.

This prompted the DA’s Bokkie Geyer to heckle Brown, calling her “racist”.

Brown responded: “Stop calling me racist. We fought racism during apartheid and we’ll continue to fight it (in the present day)”.

The ANC benches responded with howls of derision as Botha claimed the DA government did not deploy its “cadres” into government or practise patronage.

DA member of the National Council of Provinces Michael de Villiers caused a chuckle when he claimed the ANC was being ridden by “Satan like a wildhorse” due to corruption in provinces governed by the party. Public Works and Transport MEC Robin Carlisle said the “racist” policies meant that his young daughter could not become a doctor, join the diplomatic corps or join Woolworths as a cashier due to race quotas.

Later he accused the previous ANC government of looting the province’s assets, saying: “They stole everything that couldn’t be bolted down.”

Carlisle said instead of supporting the poor, the ANC government had built the Gautrain for the rich, along with other projects for those already rich.

quinton.mtyala@inl.co.za - Cape Times

sign up

Share |  

Facebook icon

Facebook

Twitter icon

Twitter

Google icon

Google

Yahoo icon

Yahoo

Reddit icon

Reddit

del.icio.us icon

del.icio.us

Pinterest icon

Pinterest

Email

Print

  • Rate this article
  • Average reader rating (0 votes) 0 Stars

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)

Mantashe, wrote

IOL Comments
07:32pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

When one looks at Brown, Rasool, Ehrenreich and the other sewage the ANC in the W Cape dredges up (there are decent individual ministers, etc in the ANC but only in other provinces, it seems) one can see why Gwede Mantashe was forced to acknowledge at the ANC's W Cape congress last year that the majority of Cosatu and ANC members voted DA in the W Cape.

Report this

IOL Comments

tony, wrote

IOL Comments
06:31pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

Brown only has to answer a few questions and I will change my mind about her. Does she support the anc secrecy bill ? Does she support the singing of kill the boer ? Does she also think all whites are racist ? does she think whites stole the land and are all thieves ? Does she support mugabe in Zim ? how many houses were built when she was premier ? does she support the arms inquiry and does she think all info should be made public. Now lets see what the answers are !!

Report this

IOL Comments

heehaw, wrote

IOL Comments
06:19pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

All I can see from the ANC in the Cape is jealousy, and envy. So they attack with no substance, just for the hell of it. Look at the face of Brown, she is like a child found out and so attacks because she has not logical reply. The Cape has turned around under the DA, and this has angered and frustrated Brown. Viva the DA Viva

Report this

IOL Comments

enrico, wrote

IOL Comments
06:02pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

The DA is a bunch of thiefs. Look at them in Plett, George and Eden! They not following procurement processes in giving contracts to their financial backers and DA stooges.

Report this

IOL Comments

democrat, wrote

IOL Comments
05:21pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

Slug it to those dullards, DA! The ANC in the W Cape has only one drum to beat and that is resentment. Cheap, nasty, self-destroying resentment. Tell 'em, Carlisle! As you say, the ANC in the Western Cape did nothing but asset-strip. They are seriously useless and thank God that the majority of voters here are sufficiently in the know to keep them out of power.

Report this

IOL Comments

aNON el politico, wrote

IOL Comments
05:03pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

anc cannot hold a debate, they inevitably resort to insults once the standard rhetoric runs out. if you anc werent such a great failure maybe more people would listen to you. unfortunately your corrupt and thieving tendencies are worn on your sleeves for everybody to see.

Report this

IOL Comments

Kalimang, wrote

IOL Comments
04:33pm on 22 February 2012
IOL Comments

Carlisle just hit the nail on the head.

Report this

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 7 of 7

Join us on

IOL-Social networks IOL-Social networks
IOL-Social networks

Mobile
on m.iol.co.za

IOL-Social networks

Newsletters
Subscribe

IOL-Social networks

RSS feeds
Subscribe

Business Directory