Road rage

All the news about the e-tolling saga...

Feud over Mandela


iol pic nt mandela4.jpg

REUTERS

Former South Africa President Nelson Mandela.

A turf war between former president Nelson Mandela’s family, the government and the Nelson Mandela Foundation created the communication crisis around his hospitalisation last week and heightened anxiety over his health.

Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe eventually stepped in to take control of the situation, neutralising the family feuds and turf wars by putting the military in charge.

Many South Africans huddled in anxious groups at work and at home last week, around television sets and radios, waiting for news of Mandela’s health, while international news crews descended on Joburg.

There were reports that at least 10 000 well-wishers, including US president Barak Obama, sent messages of support for South Africa’s first democratic leader.

Yesterday, the Nelson Mandela Foundation said it could not be held responsible for the communications mess, but admitted that “there were serious mistakes”, and the government acknowledged that it had learnt a lesson from the crisis.

While speculation about Mandela’s “impending death” spread like wildfire last week, tensions raged among those responsible for taking care of his affairs.

Several sources in the government, the ANC and those close to the foundation confirmed the differences.

Weekend Argus has learned the foundation initially refused the Department of Defence’s request to handle communications on Wednesday after Mandela was transported from Cape Town to an air force base in Pretoria, to treat what Surgeon-General Vejay Ramlakan later described as an acute respiratory infection.

Even attempts by Defence Minister Lindiwe Sisulu to issue a statement were apparently undermined by a vague, one-line statement from the foundation that it was only a routine checkup.

Head of communications at the foundation, Sello Hatang, yesterday said it was “the issue of timing on who issues what (statement)”.

He said the foundation was aware of protocol.

The foundation’s CEO, Achmat Dangor, according to a reliable source, called most of the trustees to reaffirm that they were the only people mandated to speak for Mandela. It is not clear whether Dangor called Motlanthe, who is also a trustee.

Hatang said: “The foundation consults regularly with its trustees on a range of issues… and this was not unique”.

Sisulu – through her spokesman Ndivhuwo Mabaya – praised the foundation’s professionalism and refused to comment on the specifics, but said Motlanthe “speaks on our behalf when he says we could have done it better”.

Another dimension to the crisis was how factions within the Mandela family clashed.

Weekend Argus understands some family members refused to allow Mandela to be admitted to 1 Military Hospital in Pretoria, insisting that his specialist Michael Plit was based in Milpark Hospital, Joburg.

Uncontrolled visits by family, politicians and other dignitaries also caused anxiety, fuelling rumours that Madiba had died.

Distressed by this, Motlanthe on Thursday night instructed the military which is responsible for the welfare of all past and current

presidents - to take over logistical operations at the hospital, limiting access to Mandela.

The military was instructed that only Mandela’s current and past wives - Graça Machel and Winnie Madikizela-Mandela - could visit him, with the presidency making it clear that even cabinet ministers could not visit his ward.

Motlanthe stressed on Friday that the Presidency would in future communicate and give regular updates on Mandela’s condition.

Motlanthe’s visit to Mandela on Friday and the ensuing press conference helped calm the nation.

But the foundation insisted that the press briefing be held at its offices, in what one source described as “a territorial battle”.

Hatang confirmed the decision, but said it was informed by the better facilities at the foundation.

Despite the initial behind-the-scenes agreement, petty squabbles continued minutes before the press briefing as some family members insisted on sitting at the top table with Motlanthe. Chief Mandla Mandela, the former president’s grandson, even answered media questions despite an initial agreement that Motlanthe would speak for all.

Mandla Mandela, according to a man who answered his phone yesterday, was “not available” for comment.

ANC secretary-general Gwede Mantashe blamed the media for propelling the hysteria, but accepted that “we must all learn from how this was handled”.

Meanwhile, Motlanthe visited Mandela yesterday after his first night back home from hospital. According to the deputy president’s spokesman, Thabo Masebe, Madiba was “resting” but managed to say a few words, including that he was happy to be at his Houghton home.

The Surgeon General of the SA National Defence Force, Vejaynand Ramlakan, left Mandela’s home after a three-hour visit yesterday and a woman with a stethoscope left shortly before him.

Yesterday there was a buzz of activity from the media outside Madiba’s Houghton home.

Visitors included the former president’s daughter, Zenani Mandela, and Bongani Fassie, son of the late diva, Brenda Fassie.

- Sunday Argus

- Additional reporting by Sapa

sign up

Share |  

Facebook icon

Facebook

Twitter icon

Twitter

Google icon

Google

Yahoo icon

Yahoo

Reddit icon

Reddit

del.icio.us icon

del.icio.us

Pinterest icon

Pinterest

Email

Print

  • Rate this article
  • Average reader rating (0 votes) 0 Stars

Papa, wrote

IOL Comments
05:50pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

Loudly South African, you seem to lack self-confidence, self-respect and a backbone. Mandela spoke of freedom, equality and justice for the people who put him in the leadership position, the ANC. Mandela was not and should not be treated as a prophet, he was merely making public the views of his organization. The same ideals he was prepared to live and die for are the same ideals Luthuli, Tambo, Sisulu, Hani, Getrude Shope, Ellen Khuzwayo, Lilian Ngoyi, Anton Lembede and many more believed in as they lived, they too were prepared to die for such ideals. This country has achieved so much since the dawn of democracy, we have also survived political hurricanes and came out unscathed because our democratic institutions are strong enough to withstand the turbulance. You and I are also human, same as all people I have mentioned above, no magic is required to forge ahead with the realization of true freedom and equality for all. I challenge you to stop idolising mortal beings and do your bit in order to keep the dream of many a freedom fighter alive, for the sake of our country and generations that will come after us. Tambo, Hani, Ngoyi, Sisulu etc are gone, so will Mandela when his time comes, but that should not spell the end of our South African Dream, or is it a case of "A Dream Deferred"?

IOL Comments

Leonard L. Ngada, wrote

IOL Comments
04:30pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

The foundation must understand that Madiba was a President and must be treated like all presidents. It will be ideal for the Foundation to leave it to the State President to address the Nation on this matter.

IOL Comments

Loudly South African, wrote

IOL Comments
04:29pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

The real tragedy is that the ideals that Mandela stood for and South Africans from all class and race groups believed in have been dead since shortly after he stood down as president. The current sad news is merely a formality.

IOL Comments

George Engel, wrote

IOL Comments
03:45pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

We all owe Madiba for saving this country. Were it not for him we would have civil war like Sudan. He and Walter Sisulu calmed the excited comrades who all wanted to take the country by force and expel the white man and repossess all their possessions. They were the mediators white resulted in a smooth transition. Many people dont realize how they stopped the war! Please consider this before you slander. Love you Madiba.

IOL Comments

Papa, wrote

IOL Comments
03:13pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

Dave and cohorts, why blame the ANC? Did you read the article? If yes, read again and again until you see exactly what is written, not what you think should have been written. The article is very clear. THE NELSON MANDELA FOUNDATION REFUSED WHEN THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE (Government)asked politely to handle communications around Mandela's illness, not for money or anthyng but because Mandela's travels and health matters are handled by the Dept of Defence. The foundation should be the one to take the blame, not the ANC. Your blind hatred for the ANC is disgusting. The first paragraph has made it very clear that the Foundation, family and Govt had differences on who should deal with communications, leave the ANC out of your stupidity you morons.

IOL Comments

alvin, wrote

IOL Comments
01:36pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

he is dying so let him die in peace

IOL Comments

PonkieDiel, wrote

IOL Comments
01:36pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

Yip a day off so we can braai and get drunk.

IOL Comments

Dodge, wrote

IOL Comments
01:30pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

Mandela, a great man, who NOBODY respects...

IOL Comments

JR, wrote

IOL Comments
01:13pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

They all want to be part of the action to gain material wealth or political Manoeuvring. They are the worst scum around. This is a time for close family to enjoy Madiba's last days and to prepare with grace and tenderness.

IOL Comments

Anonymous, wrote

IOL Comments
01:09pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

Why can't EVERYBODY just leave him alone? He is old, will eventually pass away so let him enjoy the time that he has left with his family and friends. Leave the man alone!!

IOL Comments

mike358, wrote

IOL Comments
01:03pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

I recall his grandson has already sold media rights for Mandelas funeral. How can a family member do such a thing ... make money from some ones death??? SICK Here is a guy who have been through a lot, treat him with respect. ANC disgusts me!!!!

IOL Comments

Andre, wrote

IOL Comments
12:45pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

And these are the clowns running the country!

IOL Comments

Bill, wrote

IOL Comments
12:23pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

These clowns don't know their left from their right!

IOL Comments

Dave, wrote

IOL Comments
12:01pm on 30 January 2011
IOL Comments

What a fiasco, the ANC behaviour as well as the media is pathetic. News Flash - Mandela is going to die ,so what ,he is old. Maybe a day off for the funeral and a public holiday as well.

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 14 of 14

Join us on

IOL-Social networks IOL-Social networks
IOL-Social networks

Mobile
on m.iol.co.za

IOL-Social networks

Newsletters
Subscribe

IOL-Social networks

RSS feeds
Subscribe

Business Directory