Vigilantes threaten to take aim at sharks

Published Nov 18, 2004

Share

A vigilante group has threatened to bait Great White sharks with chickens stuffed with broken glass, and to "shoot every shark we see" in False Bay.

A caller to the Cape Times on Wednesday said the group was from Fish Hoek and Kalk Bay.

"We're going to use broken glass in chickens as bait. We're going to take out these Great Whites. We're going to shoot every shark we see," said the caller, who would not identify himself.

Hermann Oosthuizen, shark expert from Marine and Coastal Management, has received a similar call.

"I told him that it was illegal to kill Great Whites in South Africa and that he would be prosecuted. I asked him if he also wanted to kill all humans since he has a far greater chance of being killed by a human than a shark."

"Since September Great Whites are also protected globally by Cites (Convention on the International Trade in Endangered Species). Humans are not part of the shark's natural diet, but sharks are wild animals and their behaviour is unpredictable. There is nothing to say they won't attack humans, but it is extremely rare," Oosthuizen said.

An average of one person a year is killed by sharks in South Africa. There are more deaths annually by lightning.

Isabelle Webb, the daughter of Tyna, 77, who was killed by a shark at Fish Hoek on Monday, was appalled by the vigilante group's intentions.

"What sick minds. My mother would be horrified. It's the same mentality that calls for the return of the death penalty. My mother had such a respect for life in any form, from the smallest ant, to everything else, including sharks. She was the most gentle person imaginable."

"What's the sense of killing sharks? The emphasis should be on research. It is a complex issue," Webb said.

She is also against the introduction of shark nets.

"The nets kill all those turtles and dolphins too. It's terrible," she said.

The Shark Concern Group has called on Environment Minister Marthinus van Schalkwyk to ban the practice of chumming to lure sharks for cage-diving tourism.

In False Bay, chumming is allowed around Seal Island only, where there is an abundance of natural chum in the form of seal faeces and urine.

Van Schalkwyk's spokesperson, Riaan Aucamp, said on Wednesday: "Marine and Coastal Management has for some time been undertaking scientific investigations into the effect, if any, on shark behaviour of shark cage-diving and the associated practice of chumming. Results are expected during 2005."

Van Schalkwyk has asked MCM to investigate other possible effects such as disposing of fishing waste and undersized fish close to bathing beaches.

- There will be a thanksgiving service for Tyna Webb at 3pm on Friday at St George's Cathedral in central Cape Town.

Related Topics: