YOUTUBE
The Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative has slammed an advertising campaign seeking to deter drunken-driving by warning male drivers they face the prospect of being raped in prison if arrested.
The Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative has slammed an advertising campaign seeking to deter drunken-driving by warning male drivers they face the prospect of being raped in prison if arrested.
“What is distressing is the near acceptance of sexual violence in prison and the fact that men are raped in prison. It is (now being) used to keep the public in fear of drinking and driving,” said Lukas Muntingh, project co-ordinator of the initiative.
He said if the ad had been targeted at women, it would have led to an “outcry”.
“But male rape for most people is an uncomfortable topic and one way of dealing with it is through humour,” said Muntingh, who added that the subtext of the ad was that “prisons were unsafe”.
“It is about exploiting sexual violence,” he said.
But the controversial ad, the brainchild of Brandhouse Beverages, has been endorsed by the Road Traffic Management Organisation and the National Transport Department, among others.
It is part of the company’s Drive Dry campaign.
In the ad, some men are seen talking about what they’re looking for in their ideal partner.
“I’m looking for a special person,” says one.
“Someone who can handle heavy situations with a smile,” says another while a third goes on to say: “These hands will never let you go.” But as the camera zooms out, the men are seen to be inmates in a prison cell sprawled on beds and mattresses.
The subtext appears a few seconds later and reads: “They’d love to meet you. Never drink and drive.”
Researcher Lorenzo Wakefield at the Community Law Centre said he thought the ad “violated the rights of prisoners”.
“It’s ridiculous and reinforces the stereotypical image that people in prison are inherently bad and can’t be rehabilitated. That is deeply concerning,” said Wakefield.
But Brandhouse’s corporate relations director, Norman Reyneker, has stuck to his guns.
He said their research had shown that 88 percent of South Africans would be deterred from drunk-driving by the prospect of arrest and incarceration.
“We wanted to create a campaign which didn’t simply create awareness but changed consumer behaviour so that they never drink and drive again,” said Reyneker.
“This is the reason we chose the angle of the campaign: to highlight a possible consequence of drunk- driving, which is that you might end up in jail.
“The campaign is not about prison life. It is about the consequences of drunk-driving.”
Reyneker said the ad had clearly had an impact and had already received some 30 000 hits on YouTube since its launch.
Corne Koch, of the Advertising Standards Authority, said: ”No formal complaints have been lodged but sometimes, with a shocking ad like this, it does happen where some people would take offence.”
She said if asked to review the ad, they would consider it within context.
aeysha.kassiem@inl.co.za - Cape Times
|
|
Is right, wrote
I think this ad is awesome. Who cares about the feelings of a drunken person. Criminals shouldnt even have rights.They dont contribute any good to society. This government should actually bring back the DEATH penalty.
Lee, wrote
I think the ad is brilliant - it instils a sense of fear and in this the avoidane of drinking and driving! Ppl seem to be reading too much into the ad to make it seem so bad.
diana, wrote
At LAST it has now actually been confirmed they know that rape is happening in the jail - why don't they do something about it and protect those that are getting raped in jail !!!!! Those guys have already been through their own hell in some way and have paid for it. I say protect those that are getting rape whether in jail or not!!!
Gwendoline, wrote
Haha @ the ad violates the prisoner's rights. Well, the reason why they're in prison is because they had violated someone else's rights in some or other way. I don't think the ad is offensive, it is what it is - male rape occurs in prisons. I don't know why people are making such a huge deal out of it, honestly.
Anonymous, wrote
Society has gone too soft and seem to cry about everything these days.. Tough stances are neccessary when dealing with our problems!!
makarapa, wrote
So are these rapists in prison like homosexuals? Then While the ad does have an impact and cause a stir, it is distasteful and counter-productive as a deterrent. The ad incites violence and criminal activity which is against the law, whether in prison or out of prison. Most alcoholics won't be scared. So the ad is just sensationalist and an overkill. Road accidents kill many people but drunken driving isn't the only cause. In this regard, it seems to imply also that anyone that may be perceived as been responsible for another's death may also be raped? Might as well ban alcohol. Crooked cops will use this as a threat to extort money. The ad implies that rape is condoned and can be used as a means of punishment. It also encourages cowardly predator style prison gang activities and glorifies these ghastly acts and justifies the abuse of others. Two wrongs don't make a right. Those narrow minded rape ad kissups on this posting should remember that these prisoners also rape people on the outside who don't drink and drive.
Michael, wrote
To my mind, the ad says more for the inadequacies of the legal system and the shortfalls of society than it does for the dangers of drunken driving. It is indeed sad that an ad campaing must rely on the consequences of those inadequacies to get the consequences of another crime across. Why could they not focus on th econsequences of a teenage life cut short (Jub-Jub case comes to mind), or the consequences of a family losing a loved one breadwinner spouse. Hell, why not even sketch the scenario (not unheard of) of the drunk party killing a friend or two? Our society is truly sick, and the government of the day is truly incompetent to deal with the task at hand.
Shannon de Beer, wrote
WTF Guys? Just DO NOT drink and drive. It's as simple as that. The advert hits home perfectly and is a perfect wake-up call to offenders. If you get to meet Bubba- it's your own fault. Why are you all getting so offended?
Gabri Rigotti, wrote
The service provider for the advertisment, the enterprises that accepted this as a message, and the readers who find this acceptable should reconsider if they belong to homo sapiens sapiens or a primal root thereof. Absurdly, many of these sanctimonious primates pray to some god or other at places of worship! Christ Himself must be wondering why on earth He ever bothered to suffer on a cross for such damaged dna beyond redemption!
Chris Brunsdon, wrote
Excellent ad and makes an impact. So go drink and drive because "Pappa" is looking very lonely right now.
pierre, wrote
I am quite amazed that anyone can think it is o.k. to rape in jail!!!! To rape a womanor man outside jail should be punishable with death; why then would it be acceptable to rape a man in jail?? We are indeed living in a sick society. This ad is disgusting;could'nt care how effective.
Anonymous, wrote
The advert is shocking and an absolute violation of the rights of prisoners. A person in prison is someone who has made a mistake and his punishment is the incarcerating. Why degrade these individuals? What a sick society we live in!
T. Lockyer, wrote
Congratulations to the government agencies involved in this campaign. After all, it is high time that the state admitted the epidemic of violent sexual abuse they are sponsoring in our prisons, and that they are both incompetent and impotent to address it. In fact, this campaign suggests they don't WANT to address it, because they see it as a valuable coercive strategy to use against the populace. The threat of rape is, of course, widely used in wars across the continent to intimidate and terrorize civilians. How noble and enlightened of the government to adopt this tactic in South Africa.
BReal, wrote
Say what you want to, the though of prison rape is MORe than enough to stop me drinking and driving...
Jerry Waterhouse, wrote
I haven't seen the ad but from what I've read above sounds like this is a very good ad.
Kaylee , wrote
I love this ad it's a eye opener for the idiots out there that do drink and drive they are the only ones to take offence! do right and you wil not have to worry about the ad!!!
Paul Coetser, wrote
Unless Lorenzo Wakefield has a more effective idea let him keep his comments to himself.
David, wrote
This is sick; they are basically acknowledging they have no control, not only in the country as a whole, but also their correctional systems where people are supposedly rehabilitated. What a sad state of affairs, people really do not have a future , rich will get richer, thought corruption and poor will get poorer , worst of all , be mistakenly caught,( this will happen in developed areas )only and you will be raped. What a message to send, hopefully this is not posted internationally!
mandy, wrote
Why hide the truth - I think it is an excellent campaign. Our jails are violent places where male rape occurs. If it deters one drunk driver and saves one life it is worth it.
Stephen, wrote
It's not like MUCH has really been done about rape in prison before; so I'm glad this ad is bringing more attention to the matter. I mean ask ANY guy about their fear of going to prison, and the FIRST thing they'll mention is rape; the whole "drop the soap" thing. This advert was built on a collective consciousness that existed LONG before the ads inception (and testimony can legitimize that collective consciousness as more than a fabrication to induce fear e.g Ross Kemp's documentaries on gangs) With that in mind, it's more impartial than most people are claiming. As for Wakefield's argument, this ad doesn't reinforce ANY stereotype, it merely displays a PORTION of the types of individuals you get in prison, and uses that to induce the fear of incarceration. This is tolerable, in my opinion, because you'd probably have to be delusional (keeping in mind one mere statistic that is the ratio of wardens to prisoners) to expect complete safety in prison from the type that is highlighted in this advert. The MOST brilliant attribute that this ad has is the ability to induce the debates mentioned above. . It's the kind of thing that gets people talking, which leads to action, as opposed to just allowing injustices to occour, whether those injustices be rape in prison or drunk driving. Thanks
Services
Business Directory