Groups differ over PNG asylum riots

Comment on this story
iol news pic SIN148_AUSTRALIA-IMMIGRATION-MANUS_0218_11 REUTERS Detainees riot at the Manus Island Detention Centre in this still image taken from video. The Australian Broadcasting Corporation has released video of clashes that took place at the Manus Island Detention Centre on Sunday. REUTERS/Australian Broadcasting Corporation via Reuters TV

SYDNEY - An asylum seeker was killed and at least 77 injured in the second riot this week at a detention centre in Papua New Guinea, Australia's immigration minister said on Tuesday.

Iran's foreign ministry said the dead man was an Iranian citizen and called for an investigation into the clash, state news agency IRNA said on Wednesday.

The facility, part of Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott's tough stance against asylum seekers, has come under fire over human rights concerns.

Immigration Minister Scott Morrison said the riot began when detainees forced their way out of the centre, but refugee advocates said it was triggered when Manus Island residents and police stormed the facility, attacking the asylum seekers.

One person among the wounded was in a critical condition with a head injury and another sustained gunshot wounds during the clashes on the small island in impoverished Papua New Guinea.

Australia uses detention centres at Manus Island and another on the tiny Pacific island of Nauru to process would-be refugees sent there after trying to get to Australia, often in unsafe boats after paying people smugglers in Indonesia.

“Our sympathies are extended to the transferees - that person's family and friends who would have been in the facility as well,” Morrison said in reference to the dead asylum seeker.

“If people choose to remove themselves from that centre then they're obviously putting themselves at much greater risk and in an environment where there is violent behaviour,” he told reporters in the northern Australian city of Darwin.

IRNA said the director general of Iran's foreign ministry for consular affairs, Seyyed Hossein Mir-Fakhar, expressed “protest and discontent towards the practice of violence and mistreatment” in a meeting with the Australian ambassador to Iran on Tuesday.

The incident followed an attempted breakout from the facility on Sunday night, when 35 asylum seekers briefly escaped. Nineteen were injured and eight arrested.

Refugee advocates said detainees and staff had told them the violence started again when police and Manus Island villagers stormed the facility after dark and began attacking detainees.

“Locals armed with machetes, pipes, sticks and stones have bashed and cut asylum seekers. One asylum seeker has been thrown from the second floor of a building; others have suffered machete cuts,” the Refugee Action Committee said in a statement.

The Sydney Morning Herald said it had spoken to a man whose brother was in the facility. Ghulam Murtaza told the paper he had received a phone call from his brother late on Monday saying villagers had come inside the compound threatening to kill them.

Britain's G4S, the world's biggest security group, which is responsible for security at the facility, said: “A number of transferees were injured after they breached the perimeter fence and the matter became a law enforcement issue for PNG authorities.”

“Claims that the transferees breached the fence following internal attacks on them by local residents are unfounded,” it said.

The firm, which employs over 620 000 people in some 120 countries, added that its staff were able to restore order within the centre without the use of force.

G4S has had a chequered time of late. In 2012 it failed to provide enough staff for the London Olympics, and has since been involved in problems with an electronic tagging contract in Britain and unrest at prisons it has run in South Africa and Britain.

Canberra's tough stance on asylum seekers, including offshore processing and a blanket ban on people arriving by boat ever settling in Australia, has been criticised by the United Nations and other groups as illegal and inhumane.

Refugee advocates say that long-term detention, combined with a lack of clarity on where and when the asylum seekers may be resettled, contribute to a host of mental health problems at the facilities.

Last month, detainees at a centre in the remote Australian territory of Christmas Island sewed their lips together as part of a hunger strike in protest over their treatment.

The unrest in Papua New Guinea quickly drew calls from critics to shut the facility. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees had already said in a November report it failed to provide “safe and humane conditions of treatment in detention”.


sign up

Comment Guidelines

  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.

  5. Verified email addresses: All users on Independent Media news sites are now required to have a verified email address before being allowed to comment on articles. You are only required to verify your email address once to have full access to commenting on articles. For more information please read our comment guidelines