Climate clash as groups hijack city rally

Comment on this story
iol scitech 04 dec nt climate clashes pic Independent Newspapers ANCYL members, employed and dressed in green as host city volunteers, clash with members of the Democratic Left Front, dressed in red, at the start of the rally yesterday. PICTURE: SANDILE NDLOVU

It was meant to be a rally to highlight civil society’s united demand for action against climate change, but tensions flared as political groups hijacked the Global Day of Action rally through the Durban city centre on Saturday.

Chants of “amandla” (“power” in Zulu) and “amalungelo ethu” (our rights) could be heard inside the International Convention Centre, venue of the COP17 conference as about 5 000 people took to the streets.

While civil society groups, trade unions, faith-based organisations and members of the public rallied against climate change, two political groups used the platform to push their own agendas.

It was a bitter twist to an otherwise peaceful event, which started at about 10am at the bottom of West Street. But shortly after the march began, the ANC Youth League, employed as COP17 volunteers and dressed in green, taunted the Democratic Left Front, a new political movement which carried posters saying “10 more years of Zuma” and sang anti-government songs.

The two groups burnt each other’s posters and fist fights broke out. Riot police had to intervene throughout the march. “The ANCYL are against our march. We are socialists,” said Democratic Left co-ordinator Alan Goatley. “We are a front for many different community organisations and interest groups. We want service delivery. They (the ANCYL) tore our placards and burnt our flags because we chanted anti-government sentiments.”

“I’m in solidarity with everyone here – but not them. They are insulting our president. These are not socialists. They are anarchists hiding as socialists,” said ANCYL KZN official Jomo Sibiya.

Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi led a group of Clicks workers and union members who demanded a R350 pay rise. Asked what this had to do with climate change, Vavi said: “It’s the right time and place to be discussing this. Jobs and climate change go hand in hand.”

Also part of the crowd was the Right2Know movement, rallying against the Protection of State Information Bill. The National Union of Mineworkers toyi-toyied for more mining jobs, contradicting environmental calls for the end of coal mining. There were also many NGOs and civil society marchers who blew vuvuzelas, calling for climate action.

No one cried at the New Orleans-style funeral procession for “King Coal”, as marchers carried his coffin. Others carried a gigantic inflated black-and-white octopus representing greedy multinational companies.

Durban-born Kumi Naidoo, executive director of Greenpeace, laughed at how, in 1985, he was arrested during an anti-apartheid march on the same street. He said: “The turnout has been decent but we need much more. This is about the unions, and labour movements, not simply NGOs, because climate change affects everybody. We want the COP17 negotiators to listen to the people, not the polluters. Every year 350 000 people die because of climate change.”

Tasneem Essop, a spokeswoman for WWF International, marched in a black-and-white panda bear T-shirt. “We want to save the Kyoto Protocol. It’s not looking good, but we still have a week. We want the heads of state to be bold.”

However, many delegates say an extension of the protocol, or the signing of a new Durban Protocol, is looking highly unlikely. “COP17 does not represent the voices of the poor. We are here to tell people how we are living in the shacks and how climate change is affecting our lives,” said Bandile Mdlalose, secretary general of Abahlali baseMjondolo, the shack dwellers movement. “Our shacks have been demolished by the floods.”

Outside the ICC, leaders from each organisation made speeches before their statements were handed to UNFCCC Executive Secretary Christiana Figueres.

Many delegates were in full support. “We are saying a lot of what these protesters are saying. We are in full support because public support is very important,” said a US NGO delegate.

Both UN and ICC security refused to open the gates when the Sunday Tribune asked to leave the premises.

Meanwhile, Sue Bannister, head of the city’s Strategic Projects Unit, said everything had gone “well”. “We’ve had no major problems.” The biggest challenge was caused by the weather.

“Any roof that could leak, did leak. So there were mop-up operations. But those have all been handled,” she said. She didn’t expect problems when state leaders arrived.

– Additional reporting by Matthew Savides - Sunday Tribune

sign up

Comment Guidelines

  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.

  5. Verified email addresses: All users on Independent Media news sites are now required to have a verified email address before being allowed to comment on articles. You are only required to verify your email address once to have full access to commenting on articles. For more information please read our comment guidelines 

weatherhappens, wrote

IOL Comments
05:21pm on 6 December 2011
IOL Comments

@Steve historically the arctic has been almost ice free a few occasions in the 1920s and 30s. Then again in the 50s. It is nothing new, happens all the time. The arctic started a slow but steady recovery 4 years ago and froze up in almost record time this year. The canary in the coal mine surrounds the lies and intentional manipulation of truth by the climate czars of the IPCC who star in the cast of Climategates 1 and 2. Read those e-mails and see how they lied and manipulated data for the sake of political expediency. The funny thing is that if the world and seas are so warm, how come Antarctica has been amassing ice at a rate of 1.47% per year for 30 years, and a new study just out highlights that it has gotten colder as well. The Medieval warming period indicates a warmer climate is more benefits than a cold one. It is high time to stop the lies of junk science of the climate cartel! May COP17 go down in absolute flames!

Report this

IOL Comments

james, wrote

IOL Comments
03:55pm on 6 December 2011
IOL Comments

Twice in the last 3 years the emails of prominent climate "scientists" have been hacked and released. Without a doubt there is a worldwide conspiracy to alter the data because they have no evidence of anything other than cooling. Does the press report this - no. Instead we get hysterical, hyped up stories that will continue to give these frauds grant money - your tax money. 3 years ago a "respected" scientist predicted that the polar ice cap would dissapear within a few months, glory be, it grew. Al Gore said the polar bear population is being decimated - there are more than ever. Do your own research folks because the mainstream media are in bed with these liars and frauds. THERE IS NO PROOF OF MAN MADE WARMING - especially since we have been in a cooling phase for more than a decade - oh yes, they say that is a sign of the warming to come, I forgot.

Report this

IOL Comments

Steve Thompson, wrote

IOL Comments
04:25pm on 4 December 2011
IOL Comments

Here is an article that outlines how the world's Arctic ice distribution and thickness has changed over the past 3 decades: http:viableopposition.blogspot.com201112our-changing-arctic-is-change-permanent.html Scientists note that the Arctic acts as the world's "canary in a coal mine" because changes in climate in the Arctic are amplified compared to what is observed at lower latitudes where most of humanity lives.

Report this

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 3 of 3