How the CrackBerry crackedComment on this story
London - The bad news from BlackBerry owner Research in Motion just gets worse, as the Canadian group has warned of an operating loss in the second quarter to June.
RIM, once the darling of the smartphone industry before being eclipsed by Apple and Samsung, appears to be waving the white flag as it has hired JP Morgan and RBC Capital to carry out a strategic review.
Thorsten Heins, the chief executive, who has been in the job only four months after taking over from the long-serving co-chief executives Mike Lazaridis and Jim Balsillie, has warned of “significant” job cuts.
His decision to seek the advice of the banks suggests he feels that RIM's ability to help itself may be fast running out.
Poor products, technical and network faults, a clunky software operating system, and a failure to embrace tablets are just some of its problems.
The options seem to be limited: it could put itself up for sale, strike a licensing deal, tie-up with another partner or tap the stock market for cash.
RESEARCH IN MOTION THE OPTIONS:
Industry analysts have speculated for at least a year that RIM is “in play”. Asian technology giants such as Samsung, HTC or LG have all been mooted as being interested. Amazon, the maker of the Kindle e-reader, above, might also come back for another try after RIM rebuffed an approach last summer.
It's important to remember RIM has a customer base of 78 million and a BBM (BlackBerry Messenger) user base of 56 million. Millions of business people rely on their BlackBerrys every day.
Another attraction is RIM's array of patents that could still be sought after by a fast-growing new tech player. That was a key motivation for Google's recent purchase of mobile firm Motorola.
However, bidders have kept their distance from RIM and the share price, which was down 7 per cent yesterday on news of the strategic review, tells its own story. The market sees no buyer.
But the 90 per cent slump in the shares since 2008 means RIM looks quite cheap at $C6bn.
Licensing and partnerships
Some sort of licensing deal or joint venture might appeal to another company as a new partner would not have to stump up a lot of cash. JP Morgan and RBC are said to be making this a key focus of the strategic review.
Any marriage would likely see RIM as the junior partner given its parlous and weakening position.
But RIM's security technology is regarded as the best in the market, which is why it remains the favoured tool for police, government and military use in countries all over the world.
The problem is that time is short for BlackBerry. As the months go by, the risk is that RIM's proprietary technology appears to fall further behind rivals such as Apple and Samsung.
Other mobile operating systems have swept the market. RIM has 80,000 apps in its store, and 15,000 for its PlayBook tablet, compared to Apple's iOS and Google's Android, which respectively have 650,000 and 500,000 apps in their stores. RIM has belatedly embraced touchscreens with its forthcoming (and delayed) BlackBerry 10 handset which does not have the trademark “external” mini-keyboard.
“BlackBerry 10 is the last chance saloon for RIM,” warned Dexter Thillien, an analyst at IHS Global Insight.
The chief executive Thorsten Heins said the banks are looking at the “feasibility of various financial strategies”, but a fundraising seems an unlikely avenue given RIM had C$2bn of cash and equivalents on the books, although any loss will eat into that buffer.
Shareholders, who have already lobbied for a change of management and strategic review, are desperate for any cash. The activist investor Jaguar Financial Corp has called for a sale of part of the company - such as the handset business and network services operation - to provide a return to shareholders. But so far no buyer has emerged.
Keep calm and carry on?
Arguably this is the position that RIM has been clinging to for months now - bar the change in chief executive and a few less than glittering product launches.
High-profile flops such as the Playbook, above, RIM's failed answer to iPad, keep chipping away at its brand equity. Only diehard fans are hopeful the BlackBerry 10 can change things.
“The delay in getting it to market is a major drawback for the company,” says Mr Thillien.
Even then “the example of Nokia and the Lumia show that launching a good device is not enough in today's market, but that any new device needs to be compelling and offer the right ecosystem alongside the hardware”, he said.
The worst-case scenario is that RIM's woes persist. Mr Thillien added: “Competitors may wait for the company to go under and acquire its most compelling assets at a knock-down price, as happened with fellow Canadian company Nortel.” - The Independent