Tonight whats on link august 10

‘These auditions are f***** up!’

Comment on this story


idols auditions

INLSA

Brett Botha was the first to face the judges at the SA Idols auditions, held at the Sandton Convention Centre. Photo: Moeletsi Mabe

They came. They stood. They sang their hearts out. Some leapt for joy, others cursed the day they ever thought of entering.

Every emotion was expressed as the first day of the SA Idols Season 8 auditions kicked off on Saturday at the Sandton Convention Centre, bringing thousands of hopefuls to extremes of joy, anger and disappointment.

“I’ve been here since 2pm on Friday. I spent the night sitting around, smoking and talking to my friends who were with me. It’s the first time I’m auditioning and I feel it’s a positive year for me… South Africa needs talent like mine,” said Charlene van Rooyen, sitting outside the boardroom where the preliminary auditions were held.

“I’ll be singing Westlife’s song I Swear It and I don’t feel intimidated by the others at all because vocally there’s nothing I can’t do,” she added confidently.

But Van Rooyen wasn’t the only confident person in the queue. Callyn-leigh Vorsyth, 20, was also sure she had the audition in the bag. She belted out soulful notes as she waited outside the auditioning room, holding the attention of other hopefuls with the pitch of her notes. While her captive audience clapped in awe of her vocal abilities, the anonymous preliminary judges thought otherwise.

Both Van Rooyen and Vorsyth didn’t make the cut, and weren’t sure why.

Between screaming profanities, an angry Van Rooyen said: “These auditions are f***** up! None of the people from our group who could really sing went through the next round. There’s a lady (talking about Vorsyth) who had the perfect voice but wasn’t taken… We need to expose Idols, what they are doing is not fair.”

Meanwhile, a confused Vorsyth said she was disappointed.

“You get eliminated and you don’t even know what went wrong. The judges should have been here while I was practising… The worst part is I have to now tell everyone I didn’t make it.”

But, being the next Idol is going to take a little more than just having great vocal ability as Lani Lombard, M-Net’s spokeswoman, explained.

“We are looking for an Idol who can speak to the hearts and souls of South Africans. Your personality has to shine through and you have to show us you have what it takes to perform in front of an audience of thousands.”

Others, such as Mary Ndou went to the auditions for the sheer fun of it. “I can’t sing to save my life, but I’m here for the wooden mic award. I heard you could win R5 000 for not being able to sing. I hope it’s true, otherwise I’ll be really mad,” she said, laughing.

This year is the first that the competition is being co-produced by TV channels M-Net and Mzansi Magic. And, the show’s host, musician ProVerb, will also be playing a more active role as co-producer of the show.

“Right from the beginning, Proverb has always brought more instinctive insights to the production of the show. He always has fresh ideas and we think his input will keep the show alive and entertaining,” Lombard added.

The next round of auditions will be held in Durban on Saturday, followed by the Cape Town and Soweto auditions.

Idols will start airing from June 3 on Sundays at 530pm on M-Net and Mzansi Magic. - The Star

To sign up for our Tonight newsletter click here

To vote on our Tonight poll click here

sign up

Share |  

Facebook icon

Facebook

Twitter icon

Twitter

Google icon

Google

Yahoo icon

Yahoo

Reddit icon

Reddit

del.icio.us icon

del.icio.us

Pinterest icon

Pinterest

Email

Print

  • Rate this article
  • Average reader rating (0 votes) 0 Stars

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)

Jared, wrote

IOL Comments
12:17pm on 10 February 2012
IOL Comments

Time for SA Idols to take the same route as Big Brother...

Report this

IOL Comments

Bridget, wrote

IOL Comments
10:41am on 9 February 2012
IOL Comments

Idols is purely for television entertainment. Two years ago it was such a farce that the wrong person was announced as the winner. I thought - hoped - that would be the end of Idols but somehow they keep on dragging out the same old tired crap. "Chart Throb" by Ben Elton is a wonderful funny dig into the world of what a farce the Idols competition is - read it if you can get your hands on it.

Report this

IOL Comments

lifelove, wrote

IOL Comments
08:17am on 7 February 2012
IOL Comments

agree agree agree. farce like miss sa. winners are orchestrated on both.

Report this

IOL Comments

JR, wrote

IOL Comments
04:42pm on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

All the idols shows across the world are a waste of time. They are about the judges who earm massive million dollar salaries to insult and demean contestants and in a lot of cases are has-been singers that are jealous of the talent that is out there. Last year's winner in SA was a disaster.

Report this

IOL Comments

Anonymous, wrote

IOL Comments
04:06pm on 6 February 2012

dave edwards, wrote

IOL Comments
03:41pm on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

i can see that many people are not happy with the judges...i agree...but imagine if idols still had the drunk and druged up judge ...4got her name ..due 2 it being and meaning nothing...the africancolouredwhite afrikanerafirican americanafrican pommy...not sure if i am south african...wait let me have a dop..LOUW...or is it LOW...what happened 2 that demented b***h.?

Report this

IOL Comments

M, wrote

IOL Comments
12:52pm on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

Agree SA Idols is a waste of time, this year they have to ensure either a black or coloured person wins because a white won last year. It's like Miss SA all a load of crap!

Report this

IOL Comments

sonja, wrote

IOL Comments
12:49pm on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

Like i said before, the show is all an act nothing is real not even the crowd waiting to audition is real they shoot and reshoot all the scenes until the producers are happy, its definately not about finding talent......what a shame as there are so many young hopefulls that only realize this after waiting 5 years to be the right age to enter onlly to find out that it is all an act...how sad

Report this

IOL Comments

What a farce!, wrote

IOL Comments
12:32pm on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

I have a friend that decided to enter as he is 30 and this would be his last chance to do so. He is a very good singersongwriter. Even though he performed an original he also did not even make it past the 1st group of judges and did not received any feedback as to why he did not make it. I will speak to him and see if he will allow me to post a link to the song he performed, would really like some feedback on what everyone thinks of both his ability as a singer and of the song he performed, as i cannot believe that he did not make it through, much less not even getting past the 1st group of judges...

Report this

IOL Comments

madhir, wrote

IOL Comments
11:50am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

a waste of time.

Report this

IOL Comments

Bradley, wrote

IOL Comments
11:42am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

I cannot understand why people are still watching this garbage. These show are nto looking for talent it's looking for people that can get ratings up. I stopped watching this crap after season 3. I cannot understand how any parent can allow their child to be subjected to such ridicule.

Report this

IOL Comments

Anonymous, wrote

IOL Comments
11:42am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

IDOLS SA is one big bore. Not an original singer in sight.No one has ever become a star of any international recognition. Its all about the judges and some boere meisie singing with a flat accent, or the inability to pronounce the words - diction terrible. DSTV drop this pathetic show please

Report this

IOL Comments

Wally, wrote

IOL Comments
11:35am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

With the likes of Gareth Cliff and his Idols cronies who know NOTHING about music, what do you expect? I refuse to watch the program because they (judges) make a mockery of real talent.

Report this

IOL Comments

Not a talent Competition, wrote

IOL Comments
11:15am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

My daughter entered and met some people who have fantastic voices...none of them made it through, the whole IDOLS process is so rehersed and staged....its not a talent competition at all its all about what publicity you will bring to the show....come on guys think about it, there are two sets of judges before you see the real judges - how do you explain the bad people getting through it it really was a talent competition???? My daughter said she is going to enter again except this time she will come in fancy dress....perhaps then she will get a real shot......

Report this

IOL Comments

LC, wrote

IOL Comments
11:02am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

Gareth Cliff is useless as a judge. Puts me off from watching.

Report this

IOL Comments

Boo-ya, wrote

IOL Comments
10:52am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

ive seenheard really shocking people cry that the judges are sheeeet, meanwhile they sing even worse. so unless u get on tv, wei wont be able to judge if these women can actually sing #justsaying

Report this

IOL Comments

Anonymous, wrote

IOL Comments
10:48am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

Can't wait to see the bad singers, I only watch the idol audition as it's the best comedy on TV. From there on the competition gets boring quickly with bad singers making it to the finals, guess the real talent in SA doesn't bother with Idols.

Report this

IOL Comments

Neon_Lily, wrote

IOL Comments
10:17am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

shame.............not

Report this

IOL Comments

Anonymous, wrote

IOL Comments
10:08am on 6 February 2012
IOL Comments

I will only watch Idols SA if there are experienced judges. Please no more of the unprofessional and unqualified judges who do not have the musicality nor the vocabulary to form a sentence. Also, please NOT Gareth Cliff!

Report this

IOL Comments

Showing items 1 - 19 of 19