Dr Kemm is a nuclear denialist

Published Dec 23, 2014

Share

KEMM is guilty of special pleading for the nuclear physics community. (Business Report, December 22) He quite plausibly says that we should trust such nuclear folk.

But he is taking a short-term view, say over the next hundred years or so.

Readers should remember that we’re still basking in the benefits bestowed on us a hundred-and-fifty years ago by physics folk like James Clerk Maxwell.

And these benefits, which generate a lot of the technically sophisticated luxury we enjoy, may yet turn out to be ephemeral. So I differ from Dr Kemm, despite having once been severely put down in public for such heresy by a late physics luminary, Edward Teller.

Perhaps in the long run, say 50 000 years or so, the whole nuclear scheme that so marvellously terminated World War 2 will prove not to have been purely beneficial.

For the sake of preserving humanity we should take a longer and sceptical view about nuclear matters.

Paul Jackson

Table View, Cape Town

Related Topics: