Google’s Fitbit deal headed for EU approval despite protests
INTERNATIONAL - Google’s $2.1 billion (R34.71 billion) takeover of fitness-monitor maker looks on track for European Union approval despite protests from consumer groups and rivals about the search giant’s move into health data and devices.
The EU hasn’t sent Alphabet Inc., Google’s parent company, a so-called statement of objections listing potential reasons to block the deal, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified because the review is confidential. The company won a five-day extension in the probe on Friday, which gives it more time to work with officials on improving the concessions, two of the people said.
While the European Commission could still send out a late filing, such a move would give the EU merger regulator very little time to formally flag concerns to Google or prepare a veto by its current Jan. 8 deadline to rule on the deal, said the people.
Progress on the Fitbit merger review would come amid mounting global scrutiny of big technology companies. The US Justice Department is expected to file a monopoly-abuse lawsuit against Google soon, as Congress prepares legislation to address alleged antitrust violations by Google, Facebook Inc., Apple Inc. and Amazon.com.
The EU in July announced it would conduct a longer probe of the Fitbit deal to look at how it might bolster Google’s “data advantage” in online advertising, how it would affect digital health care and whether it would be more difficult for third-party devices to work with Google’s Android phone software.
Not sending objections, which are key for any merger ban, “is a sign that the commission is closer to clearing this,” said Ioannis Kokkoris, a law professor at Queen Mary University of London.
He said that skipping objections “can be either because you don’t have enough” to substantiate potential red flags in a complex and relatively new area for regulators “or because you’re still trying to sort out the issues” at a time when the EU is also drafting rules for how big tech should treat customers and competitors.
The Brussels-based commission has asked follow-up questions about an offer Google made last month that competitors complained still didn’t go far enough, the people said. Google has until at least early November to make substantial changes to its undertaking.
In a statement ahead of Friday’s extension, Google repeated its stance that the deal is “about devices, not data” and that it faces plenty of competition for the “crowded” wearables space.
Alphabet shares advanced 0.7 percent and Fitbit shares rose 1.4 percent at 12:46 p.m. in New York.
“We have been working with the European Commission on an updated approach to safeguard consumers’ expectations that Fitbit device data won’t be used for advertising,” it said. “We’re also formalizing our longstanding commitment to supporting other wearable manufacturers on Android and to continue to allow Fitbit users to connect to third-party services.”
Google declined to comment on the new deadline. The EU’s press office declined to comment on the merger review.
The company pledged last month to support other wearable manufacturers on Android and maintain Fitbit’s access to third-party services, building on an earlier promise not to use Fitbit data for Google ads.
Rivals complained that the access offered to rival devices and apps was extremely limited and might not provide up-to-date information needed for their products to work seamlessly with Google’s, the people said. Other questions are whether the company’s pledge should have a time limit or remain open-ended to cover new issues yet to emerge and how the company’s promises could be policed, they said.
“Google may have many many ways to circumvent” any data-access offer, said Aitor Ortiz, an analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence. “It’s difficult to know how Google works internally and how they manage that. If it were a factory you could see tracks coming in and out but this is data and different places that you can’t really follow.”