Italian researchers found that dogs possess a key 'building-block' of empathy which allows them to mimic emotional behaviour.
Italian researchers found that dogs possess a key 'building-block' of empathy which allows them to mimic emotional behaviour.

A dog is a child's best friend?

By STEVE CONNOR Time of article published Nov 3, 2015

Share this article:

London - Children are less likely to suffer asthma if they grow up in a household with a dog compared to children in families without a pet canine, according to the largest study of its kind into the relationship between the respiratory disease and early exposure to animals.

The study, carried out on a national databank of more than one million children born in Sweden between 2001 and 2010, also found that asthma was about half as common in children regularly exposed to farm animals compared to the typical population.

The findings support the “hygiene hypothesis” of immune-related illnesses such as asthma, which postulates that exposure to dirt and microbes in early childhood may prevent the immune system from “over-reacting” in a way that triggers allergic or auto-immune disorders.

Swedish scientists cross-linked the country's national medical records system, which identifies every person from birth through a unique ID number, with Sweden's dog-licence register to analyse the relationship between dog ownership in the first year of a child's life and the incidence of asthma in children up to the age of six.

They found that children who have grown up with dogs in the house since birth had about a 15 percent decreased risk of asthma by the time they attended school compared with children whose families did not have a dog, according to the study published in the journal JAMA Pediatrics.

The link between early exposure to animals and a decreased risk of asthma was even more pronounced in the children of registered farm-animal workers, who had a 52 percent reduced risk of the disorder in school-aged children. “Earlier studies have shown that growing up on a farm reduces a child's risk of asthma to about half. We wanted to see if this relationship was true also for children growing up with dogs in their homes,” said Tove Fall, assistant professor of epidemiology at Uppsala University.

“Our results confirmed the farming effect, and we also saw that children who grew up with dogs had about 15 percent less asthma than children without dogs,” Dr Fall said, adding that the researchers eliminated possibly confounding effects such as socio-economic status, place of residence or whether parents also suffered from asthma.

The study is the biggest of its kind given that it analysed the health records of 376 638 pre-school children and 276 298 school-age children, and identified about 75 000 children in the two groups who were regularly exposed to either pet dogs or farm animals since the first year of their lives.

Dr Fall added that the main message of the study is that new parents who already have dogs should not be worried about their pets being in contact with young children, but that acquiring a dog after a child has developed asthma will not treat the condition.

“You shouldn't be afraid of having a dog in the house, but we do not yet know why having a dog appears to lower the risk of asthma in young children,” Dr Fall said.

However, some children develop allergies to dogs or cats and they should avoid being exposed to them, according to Catarina Almqvist, a clinical epidemiologist at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, who collaborated in the study.

“These kinds of epidemiological studies look for associations in large populations but do not provide answers on whether and how animals could protect children from developing asthma,” she explained.

“We know that children with an established allergy to cats or dogs should avoid them, but our results also indicate that children who grow up with dogs in their home have reduced risks of asthma later in life.”



No one can explain the rise in childhood allergic diseases, such as asthma, eczema and hay fever, nor the increase in auto-immune diseases, where the body’s immune defences attacks healthy tissues.

This increase in the West has not been mirrored in developing countries, where children are regularly exposed to dangerous parasites and pathogens such as tapeworms and malaria. Scientists have suggested there may be a link between the increase in allergies and reduced microbial exposure in early childhood brought about by better hygiene – this is called the hygiene hypothesis.

The idea is that by being exposed from an early age to the kinds of germs that our immune system has evolved to attack, there is less chance of the immune defences going awry and focusing on healthy tissue or harmless “allergens” in the environment, such as house-dust.

However, scientists are divided on this and few would recommend that parents should relax their hygiene standards to the extent of deliberately exposing their children to dirt and harmful infections. The latest study has shown, for instance, that exposure to farm animals lessens the risk of asthma, but some children are known to have become seriously ill from E coli passed from livestock.

Likewise, children in Africa may suffer less from asthma and hay fever than children in Britain, but they die in their thousands from microbial and parasitic infections caught as a result of poor hygiene.


The Independent

Share this article:

Related Articles