The man Pakistan doesn't know how to execute

In this September 22, 2015 handout photo, Pakistani prisoner and convicted murdered Abdul Basit, lies on a hospital bed in Faisalabad. Picture: afp/ Justice Project Pakistan Non-Profit Organization

In this September 22, 2015 handout photo, Pakistani prisoner and convicted murdered Abdul Basit, lies on a hospital bed in Faisalabad. Picture: afp/ Justice Project Pakistan Non-Profit Organization

Published Apr 26, 2016


A paralysed death-row prisoner in Pakistan is living in conditions worse than hell after his stay of execution expired, his family has said.

Abdul Basit, who was convicted of murder in 2009, has had three executions called off at the last minute over the past year because Pakistan's prison rules do not include provisions for hanging people in wheelchairs.

Under Pakistani law, a prisoner sentenced to death should be able to “reach the execution point on his own feet”.

Campaigners say hanging a man in a wheelchair involves a substantial risk of problems - and fear that Basit would be slowly strangled or decapitated.

The 44-year-old, his family and his legal team are calling on the government to grant him clemency, despite no pardon having been granted to any death-row prisoner since a moratorium on executions was lifted in the country in 2014.

Mr Basit's mother, Nurat Parveen, told The Independent: “My son has lived in conditions worse than hell while he was paralysed. His life itself has become a bigger punishment than death. The only hope left for him is to live enough for those who are dependent on him emotionally.”

She said the family was happy when Pakistan's President Mamnoon Hussain initially issued the stay of execution, declaring her son unfit for execution.

But she said: “We are also afraid - what will happen now the stay has expired? When we think about it, we find ourselves in a limbo and don't know what are they [the government] going to do with my son.

“I beg Mr President, Mr Prime Minister and the judiciary, please have mercy on my son. He has already suffered a lot. He is already half dead. What will they get if they execute a paralysed man, a helpless paralysed man who is already in prison for life? Basit deserves mercy.”

Mr Basit was sentenced to death in 2009, and was moved from Sahiwal jail to Faisalabad's central jail a year later.

However, after a few months in the facility he contracted tuberculosis meningitis.

Complications with the illness - which lawyers say were a result of negligence - caused him to lose all movement in his limbs, and he was rendered incontinent.

Wassam Waheed, a spokesman for legal aid group Justice Project Pakistan, said Basit was in a coma for 22 days after contracting the illness, and has since “spent six years on the prison floor, unable to move and reliant on others for personal hygiene”.

“Basit has always maintained his innocence, he said. He has endured a fate much worse than death time and time again. The danger remains that in the absence of instructions from the federal government, the jail authorities are likely to forward a request for a fresh warrant of execution in the coming days. If that happens, Basit will once again have to endure being segregated and count down the hours to his death.

A report by UN special rapporteur on torture Juan Méndez, published in February this year, urged the government of Pakistan to “refrain from carrying out death sentences and abolish the practice of executions”.

“In sentencing Mr Basit, a person suffering from a disability, to death, [the government] has violated his right to be free from torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment,” it said.

The Pakistan Government lifted a moratorium on executions in December 2014 following a Taliban attack on a school in Peshawar which claimed the lives of 134 students and 19 adults.

From the end of the suspension until February this year, 351 people were executed in the country. Despite claims from the government that the death penalty was intended to target terrorists, a report by the human rights group Reprieve found 90 percent of those executed had no terrorist links.

The report said Pakistan now ranked third in the world for executions, behind only Iran and China.

The Independent

Related Topics: