Independent Online

Saturday, May 21, 2022

Like us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterView weather by locationView market indicators

’The people have spoken’: Judges reject two more US election challenges

US President Donald Trump Picture: Reuters/Jonathan Ernst

US President Donald Trump Picture: Reuters/Jonathan Ernst

Published Dec 7, 2020


New York – US judges on Monday rejected bids led by an ally of President Donald Trump to decertify president-elect Joe Biden's victories in Michigan and Georgia because of unsubstantiated election irregularities and to have Trump declared the winner in both states, the latest failed efforts to upend the election results.

Both lawsuits were filed on November 25 by Sidney Powell, a former lawyer for the Trump campaign, on behalf of groups of Republican voters. Trump and his allies have lost numerous cases aimed at overturning election results in states Trump lost in the November 3 election after winning them in 2016, making unfounded claims of fraud.

Story continues below Advertisement

US District Judge Linda Parker in Detroit and US District Judge Timothy Batten in Atlanta ruled that the plaintiffs lacked the legal standing to bring the lawsuits and that the cases were filed too late.

"The people have spoken," Judge Parker wrote, referring to the election results.

Batten said a hearing on Monday that the plaintiffs were seeking "perhaps the most extraordinary relief ever sought" in connection with an election.

"They want this court to substitute its judgment for that of two-and-a-half million Georgia voters who voted for Joe Biden and this I am unwilling to do," Judge Batten said.

Powell did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Biden won Michigan by about 154 000 votes and Georgia by about 12 000 votes, giving him 16 electoral votes from each state.

Story continues below Advertisement

Biden amassed 306 electoral votes to Trump's 232 in the state-by-state Electoral College that determines the winner of a presidential election. The Electoral College meets on December 14 to formally cast the votes.

Trump, who has falsely claimed that he won the election, and his allies have waged an unsuccessful legal battle to try to undo the election results. Judges have also rejected cases in Arizona, Pennsylvania, Nevada and Wisconsin.

"This lawsuit seems to be less about achieving the relief plaintiffs seek - as much of that relief is beyond the power of this court - and more about the impact of their allegations on people's faith in the democratic process and their trust in our government," Parker added.

Story continues below Advertisement

Democrats and others have accused Trump of trying to harm public confidence in the integrity of US elections and undermine American democracy.

A majority of Republicans inrecent opinion polls have said they believe Trump won the election and that it was stolen through voter fraud. State election officials have said there is no evidence of such fraud.

Tuesday is the so-called safe harbour deadline for states to resolve disputes arising from the election. Under US law, Congress will consider a state's election result to be "conclusive" if it is finalised by the safe harbour date.

Story continues below Advertisement