OPINION: Seeking sanity in an upside-down world
Then, for good measure, we can add a dose of yield curve inversion in the US, a phenomenon that has been followed by a recession every time in the past 60 years - with only one exception in the late 1960s. Altogether, this makes for a high-risk economic and political cocktail. Yet, notwithstanding this, markets have pushed into territory of crazy valuations and perverse investment activity.
Take Denmark’s Jyske Bank, which recently launched the world’s first negative interest rate mortgage - offering home loans at minus 0.5percent a year on a 10-year mortgage. Negative interest rates effectively mean that a bank pays you to take their money. Over the life of the loan, you pay back less than you borrowed.
The insanity of “upside-down banking” had spread from bond markets where, recently, Germany sold the world’s first 30-year bond offering a zero coupon. The German bond was issued on an effective yield of minus 0.2 percent, meaning investors are guaranteed to lose money on the 30-year investment. In total, about half of all European government bonds have a negative yield, and globally there is $15 trillion (R221.53trln) in negative-yield debt.
Equity markets also have produced some astounding valuations, seen in profitless initial public offerings (IPOs). Loss-making Uber came to market at a share price of $45 in May, valuing it at $82 billion, or seven times its annual revenue. The global average for all businesses is less than two times revenue. When valuations get carried away - whether bonds, equities, tech or tulips - it never ends well. Yet, investment decisions have become heavily distracted by breathless storytelling of new business models, disruptive technologies and quantitative easing, leading to lofty valuations.
To manage this risk and successfully navigate the current environment, we should remember that sound investment decisions are founded on a core principle of buying good assets at good prices. Importantly, the one doesn’t replace the other: paying a low price for a bad asset is a bad investment.
Utilising these criteria, the most loved destinations for investors with low risk appetites - cash and bonds - start to look risky. Negative interest rates are high risk. By contrast, precious metals - widely shunned for paying zero interest - might be a sensible bet. Consider that, at $1500/oz, the gold price has risen 26 percent over the past year, and silver almost 20 percent.
In equities, new business models might also be wearing the emperor’s clothes. Uber came to market with the largest loss for an IPO. The share price is down 25 percent since listing, and there is a growing view that it may never produce a profit, potentially leaving the business worth substantially less than the $82bn price tag at IPO.
Indeed, with excessive valuation marked as a key risk, the most sought-after equity markets - which include the loved US, safe Switzerland and fast-growing India - might also prove dangerous. Using cashflow, revenue, earnings and balance sheet valuations, these three markets are trading at substantial premiums to the world average. By contrast, snubbed China, stalled South Africa and sleepy Japan are trading at discounts of between 20 and 30 percent to the global average.
Adrian Saville is the chief executive of Cannon Asset Managers.