Is Black Twitter casting a shade?
Share this article:
Washington - If you haven’t yet experienced the glory of Black Twitter, you are late to the party. But that’s okay. You’re here now.
Sip your tea, mind the shade.
Confused? Keep reading. We’ll get to that.
Black Twitter is part cultural force, cudgel, entertainment and refuge. It is its own society within Twitter, replete with inside jokes, slang and rules, centred on the interests of young blacks online – almost a quarter of all US black internet users are on Twitter.
There’s no password. The only entry fee is knowledge. If you’ve spent time steeped in black culture, whether at a historically black college or university or in the company of friends or family, you will probably understand the references on Black Twitter.
“To me, Black Twitter is essentially an extension of my black urban experience,” said Michael Arceneaux, who penned a list of Black Twitter’s 2013 All-Stars for Complex Magazine. “It’s a bunch of people like me. Black people in major cities and it’s basically six degrees of separation. I might not know you, but I might have a friend of a friend of a friend who does.”
You can observe its power and impact in the witty, sharply worded rebukes that haunt public figures when they do or say something stupid, especially if it’s racially insensitive.
In December, feminist singer Ani DiFranco announced that she was holding her Righteous Retreat at Nottoway Plantation in White Castle, Louisiana. Black feminists charged the artist with trying to advance the goals of (supposedly inclusive) feminism while dismissing black women and their experiences.
“When (a black woman) says phrases like ‘Mistress Epps Feminism’, think about why. This isn’t even hyperbole,” said Trudy (@gradientlair), referring to the wife of the plantation owner from 12 Years a Slave.
Most of the tweets directed at DiFranco conveyed anger and disappointment at someone who for years had been regarded as an ally of social justice. It was just too bitter and upsetting to joke about, but @blackconseco demonstrated a bit of well-executed gallows humour:
“@anidifranco #BlackTwitter be judging all slave plantations by the actions of a few slave plantations. #RighteousRetreat,” he tweeted.
DiFranco cancelled the retreat, then issued an apology in two posts on her website.
Justine Sacco, a public relations executive at InterActiveCorp, discovered the power of Black Twitter when she tweeted, “Going to Africa. Hope I don’t get AIDS. Just kidding. I’m white!”
#HasJustineLandedYet became a trending topic worldwide, as the internet waited for Sacco’s flight to land so she could respond to criticism of her tweet. Within days, Sacco was fired.
Unvarnished anger isn’t very effective; it’s too easy to dismiss as an emotional and irrational response, and it’s exhausting. But when humour accompanies it, the whole message seems to stick: #PaulasBestDishes, #GreenPeopleBeLike, and #PoliticosBlackIntellectuals trended not just because they shined an unrelenting spotlight on racism, but because they also made people laugh in the process.
After Food Network personality Paula Deen admitted in a deposition that she’d used the N-word, told racist jokes and harboured nostalgia for the antebellum South, users lampooned Deen with mock recipe ideas.
“Let My People Gumbo #PaulasBestDishes,” tweeted @ashoncrawley. “#PaulasBestDishes Don’t Know Nothin’ Bout Birthin No Baby Carrots,” tweeted @alpha1906.
“What was most impressive to me with the Paula Deen situation was the broader principle of taking prejudice against you and making it utterly indefensible by ridiculing it,” said Jelani Cobb, director of the Institute for African American Studies at the University of Connecticut, and creator of #PoliticosBlackIntellectuals. “People saw it as so antiquated that the perfect response was humour. Almost like The Producers. The ultimate gesture of contempt is to laugh.”
Twitter gets a lot of attention for dragging – as in virtually dragging someone through the mud – but it also serves as a mechanism for activism, as it was during the Arab Spring.
In America, the rallying cry surrounding the death of 19-year-old Renisha McBride began with writer and activist Dream Hampton tweeting about McBride before going to Detroit to demand justice for her. McBride, who was black, was shot and killed by Theodore Wafer, who is white, when she knocked on his door to ask for help after crashing her car.
Similarly, Black Twitter helped squash a book deal for Juror B37, who planned to write her account of the George Zimmerman trial after Zimmerman was acquitted of charges in the death of Trayvon Martin.
Genie Lauren (@moreandagain) tracked down contact information for literary agent Sharlene Martin, who was going to represent the juror. Lauren posted Martin’s Twitter handle, e-mail address and other information and implored her not to let the juror profit from Trayvon Martin’s slaying. She urged her followers to do the same. Scores of people tweeted the agent and 1 343 people signed a Change.org petition in protest.
Within hours, the agent and the juror released a statement saying the book deal was off.
African-Americans use Twitter at higher rates than other ethnic groups. According to a study last year by the Pew Research Centre, more than a quarter of all black internet users are on Twitter. The same study found that 30 percent of internet users on Twitter were between the ages of 18 and 29.
Those large numbers mean that a community has evolved online to reflect one that has long existed offline. The difference is now it’s out in the open for anyone to observe.
“For us, there’s a lot of barber, beauty shop talk,” said Jamilah Lemieux, digital news and life editor for Ebony magazine.
Then there’s some minor injustice that takes place: a journalist or a major outlet says something terribly offensive, we’re on the attack. Or there’s a grave injustice like Trayvon Martin’s murder or the death of Renisha McBride, we’re all there.”
Sometimes observation leads to ham-handed participation. Recent flare-ups between Black Twitter and the larger online community reveal a certain defiance: feel free to lurk, and even participate, but do not expect to be spoon-fed explanations of critical race theory or intersectionality.
The prevailing sensibility is that if you can find Black Twitter, you can Google the concepts you don’t understand. Most participants are unwilling to act as black social media sherpas.
There’s a mixture of suspicion and bemusement toward media coverage that treats Black Twitter as little more than an anthropological phenomenon that needs to be studied. (See#BlackTwitterWelcomeManual.)
That’s what happened with #solidarityisforwhitewomen, a hashtag started by Mikki Kendall, one of the creators of @hoodfeminism, to sound off about racism and privilege within the feminist community. An example was How to be a Woman author Caitlin Moran’s flippant and unapologetic disregard for the lack of diversity on the HBO show Girls.
Moran tweeted that she wouldn’t press the show’s creator, Lena Dunham, about the issue in an interview because she “literally couldn't give a s**t about it”. #Solidarityisforwhitewomen touched a nerve with feminists of colour all over the globe, and there was an eventual backlash from white feminists who felt they were being targeted, which led to #stopblaming whitewomenweneedunity. Part of that conversation involved a dismissal of intersectionality, or an insistence that black women do the work of shepherding people through the concept when a huge library of black feminist thought already exists to do just that.
Understanding the ethos of Black Twitter can be a high bar to clear if you’ve never socialised significantly with black people.
You may not understand that when someone says “*sips tea*” they don’t mean it literally. It’s shorthand for conveying a low, barely perceptible drone of contempt, similar to the backhanded compliments and clever passive-aggression that comprise shade. Plenty of cultures have shade, even if it’s not identified as such.
When a Southerner wraps a well-concealed insult with a treacly “Bless your heart,” she is being shady. There are levels.
“You’re going to see this language that’s used, that’s common to all, that you don’t have to code-switch and explain to outsiders,” said Meredith Clark, a PhD candidate in mass communication at the University of North Carolina, who is writing her dissertation on Black Twitter.
“They don’t explain to outside observers why they use this language and what certain references mean. You kind of have to be part of the community and bring that background with you in order to participate.”
The forces behind the BET show Being Mary Jane have been deliberate about engaging their audience via Twitter, especially after Black Twitter bolstered the success of the ABC hit Scandal. It has paid off. The show’s second season premiered to 3.3 million viewers, and #BeingMaryJane was one of the trending topics of the night.
Writers included dog whistles to Black Twitter in the script, the most obvious being a reference to edges. Hair edges, whether you have them, and if they’re smooth, are a running joke on Black Twitter, similar to black folks’ obsession with cocoa butter.
Poor haircare can leave you edgeless, and that’s a fate no one wants – if you pull on the edges of your hairline too much, they can fall out, never to return.
Chilli of TLC may be the high priestess of edges.
Perhaps the most significant contribution of Black Twitter is that it increases visibility of black people online, and in doing so, dismantles the idea that white is standard and everything else is “other”.
It’s a radical demand for acceptance by simply existing – or sometimes dominating – in a space and being yourself, without apology or explanation.
When Drake hosted Saturday Night Live last weekend, and Sasheer Zamata debuted as the first black woman in the cast since 2007, Black Twitter was watching. It was part of the mechanism that held NBC accountable. It will be waiting, with bated breath, to see if Lupita Nyong’o wins the Oscar for best supporting actress.
“Is this unique to the American experience? Not really,” Clark said.
“We’ve been here all along, and that’s kind of the way things go in America. We take for granted what already exists, and just because you haven’t experienced it before, you introduce it to others as totally new, and in fact, it’s not.” – The Washington Post