Independent Online

Friday, May 27, 2022

Like us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterView weather by locationView market indicators

Seconds from disaster: Pilots pulled in opposite directions in Air France landing scare

File photo: About 20% of accidents take place on approach or landing, more than any other flight phase, according to Airbus data. Picture: AP

File photo: About 20% of accidents take place on approach or landing, more than any other flight phase, according to Airbus data. Picture: AP

Published Apr 29, 2022

Share

Paris - Air France pilots who reported their Boeing 777 was failing to respond while preparing to land earlier this month simultaneously pulled the controls in opposite directions, French investigators said.

Flight 11 was on final approach to Paris Charles de Gaulle airport with 177 passengers on board after a six-hour trip from New York when the landing was abruptly aborted on April 5.

Story continues below Advertisement

In a radio exchange circulated on the Internet, a pilot was overheard in the background exclaiming "stop, stop" and the captain told the tower the jetliner was "all over the place".

In a preliminary report, France's BEA air accident investigation agency said the two pilots "simultaneously made inputs on the controls" during a go-around for a second attempt.

The agency has classified the event as a "serious incident", an industry term meaning it could have resulted in an accident.

"The captain held the control column in a slightly nose-down position while the co-pilot made several, more pronounced, nose-up inputs," the report said.

Story continues below Advertisement

"Our crew are trained and regularly rehearse procedures that are practised by all airlines," Air France said.

Boeing declined comment.

The Boeing 777 is equipped with control columns that move in sympathy with each other to aid co-ordination. Experts say only one pilot is usually expected to be actively flying at a time.

Story continues below Advertisement

If opposing forces on the two columns pass a certain limit, the link between them is deactivated or "desynchronised" to prevent accidents in the case of one side getting jammed.

After the landing scare, the pilots analysed the situation but did not notice that they had made contradictory inputs nor that the columns had become decoupled, the BEA said.

The plane landed safely on a second attempt and resumed service just over two weeks later, according to Flight Radar24.

Story continues below Advertisement

The BEA said "no anomaly was observed on the aeroplane" but added that it was continuing to analyse data. Its investigations are designed to prevent accidents rather than apportion blame.

About 20% of accidents take place on approach or landing, more than any other flight phase, according to Airbus data.

Related Topics:

SafetyPublic Transport

Share