Jennifer's fate still a mystery

Comment on this story
dna INLSA FILE PHOTO: David Klatzow a forensic scientist at his home. Picture Brenton Geach

Cape Town - It has been almost three weeks since police recovered the body of a girl they suspect to be 12-year-old Jennifer Williams, who went missing on December 20 near her Parkwood home, but they are yet to confirm this by DNA analysis.

Forensic expert David Klatzow said this was an unacceptable amount of time for the Williams family to wait for clarity on Jennifer’s fate. “It takes 48 hours to get a DNA result, 72 hours maximum,” he said.

Klatzow said that while the body was probably already decomposing when it was discovered, it was still relatively fresh and therefore simple to extract the DNA: “You would think this was a priority case. What if it turns out it’s not her body? Now, a month down the line, they have severely diminished their chances of finding her.”

Klatzow said that South African forensic labs were incredibly slow and didn’t stand up to the high standards in places such as the UK. But Professor Lorna Martin, head of UCT’s division for forensic medicine and toxicology, said a one-month wait for a DNA result wasn’t unreasonable at all.

“There are a large amount of tests we have to conduct, and many cases we are working on,” she said.

She said the tests took on average three days, from admission to the mortuary to completion of the autopsy.

These results are communicated to the investigating officer and a provisional report is filed.

But Martin said the other tests could often take a bit longer, especially those that are provided to the forensic pathology service by external agencies.

Carolyn Hancock, of lobby group DNA Project, said forensics was a far more involved process than TV shows such as CSI made it out to be.

“There are multiple labs and people specialising in different fields,” she said. “There isn’t just one mastermind pathologist calling all the shots.”

But she said that in cases where a body was being identified, especially if reference DNA had been provided by the family, the lab process should take no longer than 24 hours. However, she added that the large amount of cases being processed by South Africa’s forensic labs often resulted in delays.

“Additionally, if a body has already started to decompose it will degrade the DNA evidence,” she said. “This means the tests might need to be done several times to get a result.”

Vanessa Lynch, also of the DNA Project, said people had to realise that every case was important to the family involved and police couldn’t just assign priority to cases that the media had picked up.

“There is such a high incidence rate in this country,” she said. “Every case is a priority to the family of the victim.”

[email protected]

Cape Argus


sign up
 
 

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.