Zuma pal scoops top job with no matricComment on this story
A supporter of President Jacob Zuma, with neither a matric certificate nor top management experience is tipped to land the R2 million job as chief operating officer of the financially-crippled SABC.
This after the SABC decided to advertise the strategic, second-most powerful post, only internally, for only three working days. According to newly-appointed group chief executive officer Lulama Mokhobo, matric was not a requirement for successful candidates.
Hlaudi Motsoeneng, essentially an ANC deployee at SABC, has had the requirements for the job, one of the key positions in the corporation’s turn-around strategy, tailor-made to suit him because he has no matric and has no managerial experience at that level.
He is the same man fingered by a KPMG probe as having lied about having a matric certificate when he applied for the post of news executive for the broadcaster’s Bloemfontein office several years ago. Should Motsoeneng land the job, he would possibly become the only COO of such a major public institution without matric.
The move has angered workers in the financially struggling organisation. They are asking how a person without an undergraduate qualification could be the second-in-command of an organisation with a R4.7 billion turnover.
At e.tv, for example, Bronwyn Keen-Young is the chief operating officer. She has a Masters degree from Wits University and a Bachelor of Law Degree (LLB) from the University of South Africa (Unisa). Before her appointment at e.tv, she co-founded the Media Monitoring Project in 1993. Another COO, Graham Wayne Dempster, of Nedbank, one of the country’s top banks, is a qualified chartered accountant and has experience in retail banking.
The Sunday Tribune learnt that Mokhobo advertised the job on Friday, but apparently deleted parts where academic qualifications were required, ostensibly to ensure Motsoeneng, who does not have a matric but has strong political backing, qualified for the position.
Staff at the SABC are now questioning the deletion of the academic qualifications from the advert and the three working days allocated to prospective candidates. Applicants have until Tuesday to apply.
They say the position needs a suitably qualified person and Motsoeneng, said to have Zuma’s ear, was not the right candidate.
The advert states that the person who would be appointed to the job should be a “commercially astute executive, with broad ranging experience of success in broadcasting”, have “well developed negotiation and relationship building skills at the most senior level” and the “ability to translate and promote the integration of new business objectives into financial, human capital and organisational development changes on an ongoing basis”. “A demonstrable passion for public service” is the last requirement for the job.
Approached for comment, Motsoeneng said “I don’t want to comment on this issue” and added “speak to the CEO. She is here with me” before handing over his cellphone to Mokhobo.
The CEO said the job did not require a degree and was open only to SABC employees. “We are looking for a candidate who understands the business of the SABC. We don’t have the time to be in a state of inertia. It does not require a degree to run a business operation. That does not require an MBA. Anybody internally can apply for this job. We are very clear that we are not opening it to everybody,” she said.
She said the position did not require technical skill but an understanding of how business operations are run. “You need the ability to oversee complex situations.”
Responding to claims that the advert is tailor-made to suit Motsoeneng, Mokhobo said: “If we (had already) decided on Hlaudi, we would have not advertised the position. We would have given it to him.”
For over four years now, the SABC has not had a permanent COO and a chief technology officer. In stark contrast to Motsoeneng, Solly Mokoetle, the last person to occupy the position permanently in 2006, had a masters degree in journalism from Canada's Carleton University and 25 years experience in broadcasting. Twelve of those years were spent in executive management at the SABC. He also obtained advanced management and finance qualifications.
His successor, Charlotte Mampane, who occupied the COO's post temporarily, had a masters degree in management from Wits University, an honours degree from Unisa and management certificates from Wits Business School.
Mokhobo is the sixth SABC CEO – including those who were appointed in an acting capacity – to be in charge of the broadcaster since 2009. Before her, there was Dali Mpofu, who quit after accepting a R14 million settlement, Gab Mampone, who left under a cloud, and Solly Mokoetle, who was also paid millions of rand before his departure.
Former chief financial officer Robin Nicholson, who also acted in the CEO’s post, has taken the SABC to court for unceremoniously terminating his contract. Phil Molefe, who was the last executive to act as CEO, has returned to his job as group executive responsible for TV and radio news.
A senior staff member not authorised to speak to the media, said: “Where have you seen such a senior position advertised for three working days? This is bad. Where have you seen a big corporation like the SABC with a COO without qualifications?”
Hannes du Buisson, the president of the Broadcasting, Electronic Media and Allied Workers Union, confirmed that his union had received “concerns and complaints” about how the advertisement was worded.
“I have received quite a lot of complaints from staff about why there is no qualifications requirement in the advertisement. I can’t say it was drafted for him but there is suspicion,” Du Buisson said.
Communication Workers’ Union spokesman Matankana Mothapo said they would support Motsoeneng’s appointment.
“Let’s not talk about his qualifications. Let’s talk about skills. He understands the SABC. In the shortest time he has been at the SABC, he has done well. We are happy with him,” Mothapo said.
In May 2008, the SABC was plunged into turmoil when its board suspended Mpofu, who had a day earlier suspended ex-news chief Snuki Zikalala for allegedly leaking a confidential document to ANC treasurer Mathews Phosa.
The document in question related to a labour case involving Motsoeneng, who was at the time a current affairs executive producer for Lesedi FM. Motsoeneng was fired in 2007 and Mpofu had pushed Zikalala to reinstate him, but Zikalala refused.
Motsoeneng, according to an internal audit document, misled the SABC about his qualifications when he landed a job as a junior reporter in 1996. The SABC had tried, at least on more than two occasions, to obtain Motsoeneng’s matric certificate but failed.
Sources say the Zuma camp, which had triumphed in Polokwane in 2007, needed to take control of the SABC in a bid to clean his image. In the run-up to the Polokwane conference, those in the Zuma camp complained that Mpofu, who was said to be in Thabo Mbeki’s camp, favoured the former president with positive coverage and Motsoeneng was his antithesis. - Sunday Tribune
@Anonymous 11:05pm 30Jan - Your government is busy anglicising you, convincing you that English is the "langweesh" of the future. Have you been asleep or what?
@Buster: Go and teach your English in England - here we want to be taught isiZulu, isiXhosa, seTswana, seSotho, Venda, etc.
Ha Ha Ha Ha......Ha Hahahahahahaa.....whoooooo! Hahahahaaaa. oe ah ah!
Frankly my dear ... I am surprised to read that there are stil people out there who watch SABC!?? Bluuuhhh, I just vomited.
This is poor reporting; nothing in your article links this man to Zuma, malicious indeed.
Why are you all so outraged? Isnt this the new South Africa we should all be so proud of? Where nepotism and party political alliances rule!!!
david October, wrote
This is a disgrace. We must challenge such an appointment in the constitutional court. South Africans must rise up as the Arabs in Northern Africa.
the people spoke regarding the tolls ... time for us to speak again ..
here i am with 3 degrees and a diploma and 35 years of teaching english home lang in 3 different countries left without a job and this piece of s*%*# gets a top job.even his damn president is an illiterate.Sis...wht next.this country is getting f*%*$#*!!
boeretrooskoerant Redaksie, wrote
Ja man - this guy has the same mindset and the same qualifications as his grand leader in the anc - he also has the same mindset - Gimme - Gimme - I demand that job ! Zoomaah!
THAT IS TOTALLY UNFAIR TOWARDS THE PEOPLE THAT ACTUALLY STUDIED AND MADE AN EFFORT TO BETTER THEMSELVES, REGARDLESS OF THE COLOUR OF THEIR SKIN.
Love SA, wrote
"What does Zuma has to do with this. Please leave our president alone, dirty media...."you anonymous you must be dumb to have put this comment on such a sensitive topic,what Media has got to do with this you Moron.You must be one of those morons who were scared to leave the ANC because Julius threatened you that you would go hungry.
What difference would Matric make? Just a few days ago Praveen Gordhan and his cronies were instrumental in depriving sick hospital patients of food when they froze finances in the Province. I think they did Matric.
Dan Esterhuyse, wrote
Give me the job at half the salary and i will make it work, but with out interference, but alas it will not happen, i am not black
How can our Government do this again? Have they not suffered enough scandal? This is not a junior position...come now...
Where are we taking this country to exactly, if this is the going rate,homelands were much better than this
Dan Esterhuyse, wrote
It is now definitely. the worst qualifications, bad work record a pal of "Shower kop Zuma" that qualifies you for a top job. They cannot run a bath of water, let alone a country. The path of success, jailtoe. parlement toe
Calm down people. Dina Pule, the minister of communications has put a stop to this. Good for her.