India gang rape shames SA

Comment on this story
Copy of iol pic wld India Gang Rape~1 [1] AP Indian men watch as a woman protests outside the court where the accused in a gang rape of a 23-year-old woman are to be tried, in New Delhi.

Johannesburg - The public outcry in India over the gang rape and murder of a 23-year-old student on a New Delhi bus has prompted soul-searching in South Africa, where some people are asking: “Why not here?”

In the seven weeks since the trainee physiotherapist was raped, assaulted with a metal bar and thrown bleeding onto a highway to die, nearly 9 000 women and children will have been sexually violated in South Africa.

In one recent case in the capital Pretoria, five men dragged a 21-year-old woman into the bushes and took turns to rape her as she walked with friends at dawn to secure a spot in a university enrolment queue.

Nearly four weeks on, police have made no arrests.

Violence against women is also endemic in India, but the brutality of the recent attack shocked even those inured to the rising wave of sexual crimes and prompted thousands of protesters into the streets. The Indian cabinet has since fast-tracked tougher new penalties for sex crimes.

In South Africa, such cases barely make a stir. In a country long known as the “rape capital of the world”, women's rights campaigners say sexual violence has almost lost the power to shock.

“We are not the only country faced with crime, sexism, patriarchal attitudes and poverty. But we seem to be the only country that goes to sleep when a rape happens,” popular radio presenter Redi Tlhabi wrote.

Comparing data across countries is difficult because of varying reporting requirements, but by any measure South Africa's sexual assault rate is off the charts. Its statistics agency concluded in 2000 that it had the highest reported rape rate of all 120 Interpol member countries.

“It points to a fundamental kind of sickness in our society, that causing extreme and life-long pain to other people is a way in which some people have fun,” said Rachel Jewkes, acting president of the Medical Research Council (MRC).

“We're still dealing with a patriarchal society, where men see themselves as privileged and doing anything they can get away with, and that includes raping.”

Although researchers cite many reasons for South Africa's high rates of sexual crime, including extreme poverty, they also point the finger at decades of white-minority rule under which many black families were broken by the need for fathers to leave home to work as migrants in apartheid-run mines and factories.

“The impact of apartheid on families is probably the most important area - the way in which apartheid destroyed family life,” Jewkes said.

Mindsets have not evolved significantly post-apartheid, and the police and justice system have failed to do their parts to protect victims and prosecute perpetrators.

In the year to April 2012, more than 64 000 sexual offences, including rape, were reported in South Africa, which has a population of 50 million people. Of these, more than 25 000 were assaults on children.

The figures could be much higher as research suggests only a fraction of rapes are reported given that the police force is seen as unsympathetic to victims. Even when suspects are caught, only 12 percent of cases end in conviction.

“It is so frustrating because when you go to the police you get the second victimization,” said Funeka Soldaat, a lesbian community activist in Cape Town's Khayelitsha township, who was gang raped by four men 17 years ago.

“The frustrating thing also is the silence among ourselves as women in the community, (the failure) to say this is not okay.”

Rape became front page news last year when seven men aged between 14 and 20 went on trial on charges of raping a mentally handicapped 17-year old girl and recording it on a cell-phone video that later went viral.

But even that incident did not spur anything like the kind of public protest seen in India.

“If the gang rape of a mentally handicapped 17-year-old failed to get thousands on the streets in protest, what will?” columnist Rachel Davis asked in January in the online publication Daily Maverick.

Last month police in North West province arrested a 43-year-old man for raping his 10-month-old niece while the baby's mother was at work. After the arrest, another female relative came forward to lay a charge against the man for a prior rape.

Some South African women believe sexual assaults have been tolerated for so long that men do not even seem to be ashamed to admit to it.

Johannesburg receptionist Luleka told of a male colleague at work who recited during a casual lunchtime discussion how, as teenagers, he and friends forced reluctant girls into sex.

“I listened to him and thought, 'He doesn't get it',” said Luleka, who did not want her family name published. “He virtually raped a young girl twenty years ago and sees nothing wrong. His defence is that girls will never say 'yes' outright to sex.”

Such attitudes make it harder for women to come forward.

“A lot of police believe rape victims are responsible for their own rape,” said Gareth Newham, head of the Crime and Justice Programme at the Institute for Security Studies based in Pretoria.

“They must have been wearing provocative clothing or been in a dark area when they shouldn't have been. They blame the victim a lot.”

Johannesburg businesswoman Andisiwe Kawa is still looking for justice after she was gang raped by five men in 2010 only to see the case against her suspected assailants dropped for lack of evidence.

Kawa, one of a tiny minority of rape victims who have publicly spoken about their attacks despite the stigma it carries, has founded a project that campaigns against rape of women and children.

“Rape has become a norm. We've become very apathetic about it. There's this silence that gives an upper hand to perpetrators because we don't tell on them,” said Kawa, who is spearheading South Africa's part in a Feb. 14 global march against gender violence.

Kawa, who is in her 50s, has lost faith in a justice system that she says allows rape cases to drag on for too long, with suspects often released on bail.

“We have a constitution that promises us the right to safety and security and justice but in reality we don't have those,” she said.

“We have this nice, world-class legislation but it is not implemented for the people on the ground who require it. It is useless legislation.”

According to South African Police there were 64,514 sexual offences cases reported in 2011/12, or 127.5 per 100,000 of the population. For a full story click on

Legal experts caution against comparisons of national crime and conviction rates because police procedures, methods of counting and recording and legal definitions of rape vary in different jurisdictions across the world.

Here is a look at police rape statistics from countries around the world from the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. The numbers in this table refer to rape meaning “sexual intercourse without valid consent”.

 

Recorded rape offences across the globe

NUMBER OF POLICE RECORDED OFFENCES

YEAR COUNTRY COUNT RATE PER 100,000 of Population

AFRICA

2009 Kenya 847 2.1

2010 Uganda 709 2.1

2008 Zimbabwe 3,198 25.6

2008 Algeria 812 2.4

2010 Botswana 1,865 92.9

2009 Lesotho 1,777 82.7

2010 Senegal 693 5.6

 

CARIBBEAN

2010 Bahamas 78 22.7

2010 Jamaica 668 24.4

 

SOUTH AMERICA

2010 Bolivia 2,587 26.1

2010 Colombia 3,149 6.8

2009 Peru 6,751 23.5

 

NORTH AMERICA

2010 Canada 576 1.7

2010 United States 84,767 27.3

 

ASIA

2010 Kyrgyzstan 314 5.9

2010 Japan 1,289 1.0

2010 Mongolia 342 12.4

2009 Philippines 5,813 6.3

2010 Thailand 4,636 6.7

2010 India 22,172 1.8

 

EUROPE

2010 Poland 1,567 4.1

2010 Moldova 368 10.3

2010 Russian Fed 4,907 3.4

2010 Ukraine 635 1.4

2010 Finland 818 15.2

2010 Sweden 5,960 63.5

2010 UK (England & Wales) 15,934 27.7

2010 Norway 938 19.2

2010 Spain 1,578 3.4

2010 Belgium 2,991 27.9

2010 Germany 7,724 9.4. - Reuters

Sources: UNODC/South African Police Service


sign up
 
 

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.