Flickr.com
The SA Literary Awards has withdrawn its award for Annelie Botes, writer of the highly acclaimed Thula Thula, for saying she did not like black people. Photo: Flickr.com
Remarks made by a prominent Afrikaans author have opened a debate about race in South Africa.
Author and columnist Annelie Botes told Rapport newspaper in an interview last week she did not like black people.
People have since either hailed Botes as “brave” or called for her to leave the country.
Asked in the Rapport interview which people she did not like, Botes paused before she answered that she would be honest despite knowing her answer would shock.
“I don’t like black people.”
She continued: “I don’t understand them! ... I know they are people just like me. I know they have the same rights as me. But I do not understand them. And then I do not like them. I avoid them because I am scared of them ... My neighbour was brutally murdered. For what?
“If black people are hungry, why don’t they, like in the old days, break in, steal the fridge and walk away? I know where their anger comes from. It has f**k all to do with apartheid. They are angry because of their own incompetence.”
Botes had since told Rapport this weekend she was not a racist and should have instead said she did not like “all black people”.
Her publishing company, NB Publishing, had distanced itself from her comments.
A number of people have tweeted their feelings, left messages on Facebook and commented on the Rapport’s website.
Zimo2 tweeted: “Why don’t you relocate you ugly minded? Are you beautiful by any chance?”
Zena wrote on the Rapport website: “I agree 100 percent with her. Too many people out there are false.”
Pierre de Vos, constitutional law expert at UCT, wrote on his blog Constitutionally Speaking that Botes’ comments were an indication of the feelings of other South Africans. “We all know now that this is not an aberration. These sentiments are rife and are supported either tacitly or more loudly by many white South Africans.”- Cape Times
* IOL is opening comments on this story as we feel it is an important debate. However, please note that we will be ruthless in our moderation: we want debate on the substance of the remarks made by Botes and on the free speech issues surrounding this. Any gratuitous racist comments or racist attacks on other posters will not be permitted. - IOL Editor
|
|
Anonymous, wrote
OMW is it ever gonna stop I mean for crying out loud we living in a very diverse country and we should be proud of that.its people like her who dont want to accept change in this country if you hate me for the colour of my skin what does that make you? Im proud of being black and nothing or no one says will make me feel ashamed of that.
Point Blank, wrote
The best part of all of this is the replies by some people. They call her racist and then proceed to insult her. Does anyone else see the irony in all of this? If you were the better person, as I am sure most are, you would feel pity for this poor woman. By racially or personally insulting her tends to prove a point to a certain degree. Reacting in the same manner as her does not make it right. She is old school and like my father-in-law you not going to change that mind setin their life time, but you can set in motion the stepping stones for future generations.
Livion Mahlangu, wrote
It is sad that at this time there are people that see other humans as second class humans. It is because of comments like these that divides the nation and digs the past which everyone is trying to put behind. I remember what P W Botha said. "A zebra will die no matter which colour stripe you shot, black or white" Think about that and then you will have a better understanding of God's creation, a human being.
Anonymous, wrote
Megan... now that a white person has said what JM and his cronies have been saying for years (in reverse) it is an issue... I do not agree with her statements of incompetence and crime... But i do believe that EVERYONE is entitled to their own opinion... This is how she feels so let her be... I have many African, colored and Indian friends and I treasure each and every one of them... especially because they are different and interesting... their beliefs upbringing religion traditions... Botes hasn't taken the time out to learn and understand SA's cultures... HER LOSS...
Anonymous, wrote
she has a right to like or dislike whoever she wants, it is her right to choose, not because we live together do we have to like one another
Anonymous, wrote
This lady needs help, thats all.
Montoane, wrote
South Africa is a democratic state, govern by constitutional democracy and some people have difficulty in accepting this notion.What this woman says is out of anger for the murder of her neighbour, however, this doesn't make all black people murderers and criminals. There are white people who also commit brutal killings of black people yet, you won't hear us saying we don't like white people because there good and evil in all the people irrespective of the race. The acts committed by few black people doesn't make us murderers, criminals and holigans. I believe that as a country we need to open a debate about race and racism, it shouldn't be a debate by politicians and experts but by an ordinary citizens of this country so that we can take this country forward. This kinds of comments comes as results that we as South Africa(irrespective of the race) we lack a common identity, something that we can all say we proudly South Africans. I hope that this woman get a chance to interact with more people then she will see that we are not that bad and scary as she thinks.
David, wrote
I agree with "Nontoh" - we are all victims of crime. Although it is her right to state her opinions, I feel that this kind of statement shows not only her unmittigated lowliness of mind (anyon who uses the term "they them" to describe a group of people shoud immediately be ignored), she is also being totally reckless. I mean, this is a country trying to move past divisiveness and here she is about to set tempers flairing. Totally ignorant, selfish and reckless. As a "white" South African, I totally distance myself from this woman!
Boer, wrote
At least she doesn't say the boer should shoot them. She simply says she doesn't like them.
Duncan, wrote
Like Donovan, I am a white male and I'm appalled at her comments. As others have said, to lump all black people together because her neighbour was murdered, is at best, racial profiling, at worst, simply racist. Unfortunately in South Africa, we're still pretty polarised and most issues are dealt with in a "you're either with us or against us" fashion, feeding into negative stereotyping. It's very sad.
Anonymous, wrote
This lady needs help, thats all.
Boer, wrote
At least she doesn't say the boer should shoot them. She simply says she doesn't like them.
Malusi, wrote
Annalie you are missing one of life's greatest blessings. Umntu ngubuntu ngabantu (Community). As a white American living in South Africa for 11 years the Xhosa people are some of my best friends, we also love the Afrikaans and have very good friends. Why do people not look at the heart? I would encourage you Annelie to come with us to the Townships and learn grace!
Juan, wrote
I respect this journalist. She tells it like it is. Most other journalists will always sacrifice the truth on the altar of political correctness. She calls a spade a 'spade' and she has the GUTS to do this!
Nitska, wrote
Generalization is almost always a bad thing. "Black people" or even "white people". Let's talk about an individual who murders or who is incompetent, as that happens, regardless of ones race. Tolerance, respect, understanding ?
Alex, wrote
Not the cleverest statement to make point, never mind being a author (..should that be was an author). Brave or stupid take your pick. But frankly she has stated a degree of truth and also from both black white sides... We do not understand each other nor our customs and that breeds dislike and hate. Whites think all blacks are murderers and all blacks think whites are given everything on a plate and then some (just the most apparent misconceptions)... We need to realise we are South African and we need to stand together for a better future for all ...the Chinese are coming and they make apartheid and Idi Amien look like fairies.
Anonymous, wrote
She is a type of person that I would sit and have a conversation with, as she expresses exactly how she feels, than sit with someone and not know what plot they have against you!!!!!! Let the truth be told, out of the abundance of the heart so shall a man speak, she spoke what was in her heart.
Ferny, wrote
Shame! And now you have tainted the general white population by your silly, short-sighted comments. Personally speaking, I find black people interesting and would rather sit with on of them and share a lunch than one of my white counterparts. You should be ashamed - especially in this day and age! Instead of denying the meaning of what you said, why don't you just apologise and make amends?
siyanda712, wrote
I agree fully with fRANCO lOUBSER, now that someone of another color has said these statements we all jump into defence mode simply because she is white!! Its her opinion and i think i'd rather live with people like her rather than living with people that i dont know what they think about me... Please go sort Malema out and then you can say what ever you like about her!!
Anonymous, wrote
I also don't understand white people, does this mean I should not like them as well? I believe her remarks are based squarely on her prejudice against black people in general. Given our history I am not surprised. Why is everyone making such a big fuss about this? Prior ’94 this would have been expected and not have even made news. Now 16 years later people expect things to be different? Our country is still healing people, stop all the pretence, just come out and say it!
Services
Business Directory