China slams Palmer’s ‘irrational attack’

Comment on this story
iol pic wld 40_CHINA AUSTRALIA-TYCOON_0820_11 Reuters Australian billionaire Clive Palmer. File picture: Olivia Harris

Beijing/Sydney - China's foreign ministry has condemned a verbal attack by Australian mining mogul and politician Clive Palmer as irrational and absurd, after the businessman described China's government as “bastards” who shoot their own people.

The Australian government has rebuked Palmer, who holds the balance of power in Parliament's upper house.

Foreign Minister Julie Bishop said she planned to contact the Chinese embassy to stress that the Australian parliament does not share Palmer's “abusive” views.

“Palmer's words about China in recent days are totally irrational and absurd. We strongly condemn them,” Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman Qin Gang said in a statement posted on the ministry's official website late on Wednesday.

Qin's statement came after a prominent Chinese newspaper, the state-run Global Times tabloid, said Australia should be taught a lesson.

“China cannot let him off, or show petty kindness just because the Australian government has condemned him,” it said in an editorial in its Chinese and English editions.

“China must be aware that Palmer's rampant rascality serves as a symbol that Australian society has an unfriendly attitude toward China.”

Qin, however, noted that Australian political leaders, including Prime Minister Tony Abbott, had criticised Palmer's actions, saying the tycoon's stance did not have the wider backing of the Australian public.

The Global Times is published by the ruling Communist Party's official People's Daily. Although it does not have the same mouthpiece function of its mother publication, its words can carry weight in government circles.

The government-run Xinhua news agency took a softer line, saying that “one rotten apple” should not be allowed to ruin relations. It noted that the Chinese embassy had received emails of support from Australians who felt embarrassed by Palmer.

Palmer is locked in a legal battle with Chinese firm CITIC Pacific Ltd over cost blowouts and disputed royalty payments at the Sino Iron project in Western Australia, China's biggest offshore mining investment.

The outspoken businessman lost two parts of that legal fight on Wednesday. The Federal Court of Australia ruled that the government was wrong to have appointed Palmer's private company Mineralogy Pty Ltd as operator of Cape Preston port, where Sino Iron is exporting its ore.

In a separate case, a federal judge ruled that the government had the right to approve CITIC Pacific's security plan for the port facilities at Cape Preston.

Mineralogy had challenged the approval in an attempt to block CITIC Pacific, controlled by state-owned CITIC Group, from exporting iron ore from the $8 billion project. CITIC bought the rights to the ore from Palmer and began shipments last December, more than three years behind schedule at nearly quadruple the original cost.

A further court challenge over some A$200 million ($185 million) in royalties is going on.

Palmer has already said his comments were not intended to refer to the Chinese people, and on Wednesday issued another statement saying he had been a “major supporter of the Chinese” for a long time.

“What is unacceptable is a Chinese state-owned enterprise that abuses the legal system for commercial gain in a global strategic effort to control resources,” Palmer said.

China is Australia's biggest trade partner with two-way trade approaching $150 billion, representing more than 20 percent of Australia's total trade.

Nev Power, chief executive of Fortescue Metals Group Ltd, which sold $11.8 billion worth of Australian iron ore to China in fiscal 2014, said he did not think the remarks would have an impact on bilateral relations.

“Clearly, they are not helpful comments. It sounded like a bit of ranting and raving. I'm sure that the Chinese will dismiss them for what they are,” he told reporters.

However, the Global Times said China should consider putting sanctions on Palmer and his companies and banning him and his senior executives from China.

“China must let those prancing provocateurs know how much of a price they pay when they deliberately rile us,” it said, adding that Australia “must be marginalised in China's global strategy”.

The newspaper implied that Australia did not mean that much to China in any case.

“Australia is a remote business partner, and a place where the Chinese can take a trip and learn some English.” - Reuters



sign up
 
 

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.