France’s justice minister in anthem row

Comment on this story
iol pic wld france national antheme taubira AFP France's minister for justice, Christine Taubira. File picture: Georges Gobet

Paris -

France's black justice minister faced calls to resign on Monday for refusing to sing the national anthem during an event to mark the end of slavery, saying it was like “karaoke”.

The centre-right main opposition UMP criticised Christine Taubira for refusing to sing the Marseillaise. The far-right National Front party demanded that she quit her post.

After critics posted remarks on her Facebook page concerning the event at Paris's Luxembourg Gardens, Taubira hit back, saying: “Some events are more a time for reflection than onstage karaoke.”

Her comments only generated more outrage from the opposition.

“What is most shocking is that she could justify herself not singing the national anthem by speaking of stage karaoke,” said UMP leader Jean-Francois Cope.

“She is a minister. There are certain things one does not say, that one does not have the right to say, and I think I am among millions of French people who are deeply shocked,” he said.

National Front leader Marine Le Pen said: “By comparing 'La Marseillaise' to ‘onstage karaoke’ and refusing to sing it, Christiane Taubira has revealed her true colours, and those of the administration.

“This unacceptable gaffe is indeed symbolic proof of the highest order of their contempt for France, for its history and its people, who love to sing their anthem, and are proud of it.”

Taubira was defended by the Socialist Prime Minister Manuel Valls on Monday, who said: “The country is bursting with these absurd controversies that waste time and divert our population from essential issues.”

Public figures who fail to sing the Marseillaise have been attacked by the far right in the past.

The National Front called for the exclusion of footballer Karim Benzema from France's national squad after he said: “I cannot be forced to sing the Marseillaise.”

Real Madrid striker Benzema was born in France to parents of Algerian descent.

Taubira, the most prominent black person in French public life, is a regular target for France's right-wing opposition, partly as a result of her having been the main government architect of last year's legislation to legalise gay marriage, and partly because she is seen as being soft on crime.

The hostility towards her has, at times, spilled over into overt racial abuse with the minister having been the subject to a string of “banana” slurs over the last year.

“It's been two years that this has been going on,” she said on TV over the weekend. “Perhaps these people that do this to me could consider finding one month with one week where they don't launch a polemic against Taubira.”

Le Pen and UMP leaders have distanced themselves from more racist attacks but commentators have interpreted them as a sign that racial slurs have become less of a taboo in French society. - Sapa-AFP


sign up
 
 

Comment Guidelines



  1. Please read our comment guidelines.
  2. Login and register, if you haven’ t already.
  3. Write your comment in the block below and click (Post As)
  4. Has a comment offended you? Hover your mouse over the comment and wait until a small triangle appears on the right-hand side. Click triangle () and select "Flag as inappropriate". Our moderators will take action if need be.