Verdict in church child sex trialComment on this story
Philadelphia - The jury reached a final decision on Friday in the case of the highest-ranking U.S. Roman Catholic official to stand trial in the church child sex abuse scandal, stemming from his job overseeing hundreds of priests in the Philadelphia Archdiocese, court officials said.
The jury deliberated 13 days before reaching a decision in the trial of Monsignor William Lynn, 61, on charges that carry the possibility of 21 years in prison.
“A decision is in; I do not know the outcome,” said court spokesman Frank Keel in an email to Reuters. He said he expected the decision to be read at 2 p.m. EDT.
Earlier in the week, the jury said it was deadlocked on all but one of five counts against Lynn and another priest.
Lynn, who for 12 years as secretary of the clergy supervised hundreds of priests in the archdiocese, was accused of conspiracy and child endangerment in what prosecutors said was an effort to cover up child sex abuse allegations, often by transferring priests to unsuspecting parishes.
The jury of seven men and five women in Common Pleas Court began deliberating earlier this month after hearing 10 weeks of testimony in a trial that re-focused attention on the broader sex abuse scandal that has rocked the Catholic Church, costing billions in settlements, driving prominent U.S. dioceses into bankruptcy and testing the faith of Roman Catholics.
In this case, Lynn's job was supervising 800 priests, including investigating sex abuse claims, from 1992 to 2004, in the nation's sixth largest Archdiocese, with 1.5 million members.
At trial, prosecutors argued that Lynn chose to protect the church at the expense of children, in an effort to avoid scandal and potential loss of financial support for the church,
The defense said Lynn tried to address cases of pedophile priests, compiling a list in 1994 of 35 accused predators and writing memos to suggest treatment and suspensions.
He was hampered because he could merely make recommendations to his boss, the head of the Archdiocese, Cardinal Anthony Bevilacqua, the defense said. Bevilacqua died in January at age 88.
According to Lynn's testimony, the cardinal said any mention of an accused priest's move from a parish should cite health reasons, never the accusations. Testimony also showed Bevilacqua ordered the list of accused priests be destroyed, although a lone copy was found in an Archdiocese safe.
That list proved to be a key piece of evidence.
Prosecutors used it to show the church was well aware of predatory priests and covered up their existence, while the defense used the same list to argue it showed Lynn attempting to stop the problem.
The jury was also considering the fate of Reverend James Brennan, 48, who was charged with child endangerment and the attempted rape of a 14-year-old child in 1996.
Attorney Marci Hamilton, who represents six alleged victims in the Lynn case, called the Philadelphia trial “a morality play,” and said she is certain it has caught the attention of the Vatican.
“There is this worldwide system of cover up, and they have to be concerned that if this could lead to a conviction in Philadelphia, this could lead to convictions everywhere,” she said.
In recent decades, thousands of cases of child sex abuse by priests have come to light, both in Europe and the United States.
The U.S. scandal erupted in 1992 with a series of sex abuse cases uncovered in the Archdiocese of Boston that helped encourage other victims of abuse to come forward.
Some 3,000 civil lawsuits alleging abuse were filed in the United States between 1984 and 2009. An unknown number of complaints - believed to be vastly more - were settled privately, often with confidentiality agreements, experts say.
The church has paid out some $2 billion in settlements to victims, bankrupting a handful of dioceses. Hefty multi-million sums were paid out by Catholic Archdiocese in Boston, Chicago and Los Angeles. The Diocese of Wilmington, Delaware declared bankruptcy in 2009, and the Diocese of Milwaukee, Wisconsin did so in 2011.
Lynn's trial was noteworthy because of its focus on the role of a church official accused not of molestation but of covering it up. It raises questions of personal responsibility and how far someone such as Lynn could or should have stepped outside the rigors of the church hierarchy and whether strict obedience to church elders is defensible, experts said.
“It exposes better than ever the real dynamics of the coverup of clergy sexual abuse,” said Richard Sipe, an author and expert in abuse cases.
Similarly, another case of child sex abuse in Pennsylvania, that of former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, also has raised questions of personal and moral responsibility.
In the case of Sandusky, whose trial elsewhere in Pennsylvania on 48 counts of child sex abuse went to the jury on Thursday, legendary football coach Joe Paterno and University President Graham Spanier were fired by the Penn State Board of Trustees for failing to do more when alerted to suspicions about Sandusky. Paterno, 85, died in January.
Hamilton, the attorney, said the question of responsibility stretches to the top of the church power structure.
“Because it is such a hierarchical institution, it does take the question all the way to the top,” she said. “We're not just talking about Monsignor Lynn and Bevilacqua. We are talking about them and the Pope. - Reuters